3 min read

I see no difference between the $33 million bond proposal to renovate the Cumberland County Civic Center and President Obama’s failed stimulus plan and proposed job’s plan.

Government should never try to create a business for itself because the only solution it has if that business plan fails is to pour more money into it. And please, let me state right from the beginning that I am not against a civic center somewhere in Cumberland County. What I am against is a civic center that was built with Cumberland County money of which the greatest amount of control came from the City of Portland.

Perhaps the greatest mistake of the voters of Cumberland County was allowing the Civic Center to be built where it is presently located. Portland certainly is not the center of the county but its superiority in numbers allowed the center to be built where it is now.

What’s even worse is that the initial design and construction lacked an outlook for the future which brings it once again to a ballot question where voters must decide as to spending even more money for something that was a failure from the beginning.

I could support the $33 million bond if I felt the civic center would generate enough income to pay for the bonds it wants along with profits that would lower tax rates in cities and towns in Cumberland County. I have no doubt that the majority of readers of this column realize that will never happen.

I glanced at the center’s website and noticed that 5,000 events have been held there. It has been in existence around 35 years, which is over 12,000 days. Yet when I look at the scheduled events on their website last Sunday all I find is a group called Further on Nov. 4, UMaine Hockey on Nov. 6, Sesame Street Live for three days in December and the Portland Pirates home games until April. Then I have a question to ask, what other events were held at the center this summer?

Advertisement

I certainly do not want my tax dollars supporting a professional hockey team that is in doubt of staying in Portland if their free ride fails to support them. Shouldn’t a for-profit sporting team pay their way? When I look at the other venues in Portland where performing artists come to on a regular basis, why can’t the civic center do the same? For me, there is only one answer and that’s because the county government has control over it and that is what must end immediately. If someone states that the center is outdated because the loading docks or facilities are inadequate, then I have no doubt that there was a failure to construct it properly in the first place.

Take, for instance, the $6 million mega berth at Portland’s Ocean Gateway terminal. It was built so larger commercial and cruise ships could dock there. One cruise ship left the dock early because there was fear that at low tide the ship would be grounded as water levels would be too low. Maine taxpayers could have the possibility of paying for yet another defunct railroad, which used to run from Portland to North Conway, the Mountain Division Rail Line. The Dirigo Health program was created to insure Maine’s high number of uninsured citizens and since it failed miserably, the only solution was to pour more tax dollars into it.

I have already voted by absentee ballot to ensure that my vote counts. Anyone who knows me already knows how I voted. But what I am happy to report to those who don’t watch the Windham Town Council in action, or inaction, is that I was happily surprised when they voted unanimously not to support a state bond that would extend the Mountain Division Rail Line from Windham to Fryeburg. I can only hope that voters do the same for the bond for the civic center.

Lane Hiltunen, of Windham, believes government sense is nonsense.

Comments are no longer available on this story