4 min read

GORHAM – Despite a barrage of neighborhood opposition, the Gorham Town Council on Tuesday unanimously approved re-opening a long-closed town landfill off Huston Road so piles of debris from a padlocked recycling plant could be deposited.

Concerns aired in the packed council chambers, where councilors heard more than three hours of arguments and questions, included health, contamination and devaluation of properties.

The town is seeking a resolution in court to allow disposal of material left at Plan-It Recycling in the Gorham Industrial Park. The town, claiming Plan-It Recycling had violations regarding the size of the piles of recyclables and clogged fire lanes, filed a lawsuit last year in an effort to force compliance. The plant is on the Gorham-Westbrook line and recyclable materials are visible from Route 25.

Earlier this year, a judge, following complaints by the town and the Maine Department of Environmental Protection, temporarily halted the Gorham plant from accepting additional material. According to information from the town, Plan-It Recycling is “now insolvent” and has “no resources to clean the site.”

Under a plan, R.J. Grondin & Sons of Gorham, who would buy out other mortgage holders, could acquire the recycling site and truck an estimated 5,000 tons of debris to Gorham’s construction and demolition debris landfill behind the Public Works Department garage off Huston Road. The landfill closed 15 years ago.

In an acquisition, said Phil Grondin Jr., of the family-owned construction company, it would pay one mortgage holder, Bank of America, $175,000 and $20,000 to another mortgage holder. The Small Business Administration is involved and Grondin said a trucking broker also has placed a lien on the property.

Advertisement

“We’re not getting rich off the deal,” Grondin said.

While Grondin would not be charged a fee to deposit the debris in the town’s landfill, the company would be responsible for costs of opening and closing Gorham’s landfill.

Brenda Caldwell, vice chairwoman of the Town Council, supported Grondin.

“I appreciate what they’re doing for the town,” Caldwell said.

But, the construction company, which is testing soil at the Plan-It site, could reject the deal.

“If it’s overly nasty, we walk away,” Grondin said.

Advertisement

If Grondin were to opt out, other options could include leaving the debris at its present site, or Gorham taxpayers could pick up the disposal costs.

Nancy Macirowski, a lawyer in the Maine Attorney General’s Office, said in Tuesday’s Town Council meeting the Plan-It property is not a hazardous waste site.

“It’s mainly an eyesore and a fire hazard,” Macirowski said.

Eric Hamlin of the Maine Department of Environmental Protection, who was last at the site two months ago, said based on observation, the material is construction and demolition debris. However, Town Councilor Philip Gagnon said he found an oil tank discarded at the site.

“That’s illegal,” Gagnon said, and he wanted assurances that the material would be appropriate to haul to Gorham’s landfill.

Hamlin said hazardous waste would not be accepted at Gorham’s landfill. He also said the debris couldn’t be buried where it is at the 8-acre Plan-It Recycling property.

Advertisement

“It’s not an option,” Hamlin said.

Grondin could begin trucking the debris in January.

“We’re looking at 60 days to complete the process,” Owens McCullough, a Sebago Technics engineer representing Grondin, said Tuesday. McCullough figured relocating the debris would require 1,500 trips by tri-axle trucks.

But the approval process could get mired down. Reopening the landfill requires Maine DEP and Gorham Planning Board approval. Town Planner Tom Poirier said utilizing the town’s landfill would require a site plan review.

William Dale, the town lawyer, said a Planning Board decision could be subject to an appeal in court. The entire plan involving all parties and removing the material needs Superior Court approval.

Town officials estimate disposing of approximately 27,000 cubic yards of debris in privately owned landfills elsewhere would cost $750,000 in fees and don’t want to burden Gorham taxpayers with clean up expenses.

Advertisement

“When I vote, it’s what is best for 17,000 residents,” Town Council Chairman Matthew Robinson said. “We’re not going to make everybody happy tonight.”

“I don’t believe we should open Pandora’s box. You need to search your conscience,” Jeri Stuart, 156 Huston Road, told town councilors.

Douglas Smith, of 81 Huston Road, said the town has an eyesore.

“We’re between a rock and a hard place,” he said.

Dennis Morton said the right decision would be to pay the $750,000.

“I’m against moving it to Huston Road,” Morton said. “I’m going to fight this. I’m not going to stop.”

Advertisement

On Wednesday, Morton sent a fiery email to Town Manager David Cole, with copies to town councilors and the American Journal.

“Not sure what happened last night,” he wrote, “but I got a feeling that the public hearing was a waste of everyone’s time, the vote to open the landfill was a done deal. The whole meeting was choreographed by you and the council to at least let the public have their two hours of ventilating and then voted as planned.”

Pete Walker of Mighty Street told the council he was worried about polluting a nearby brook in addition to well water.

“My property is on an aquifer,” Walker said. “I don’t want to worry about the water.”

“This neighborhood is taking a hit,” Richard Curtis of Wards Hill Road said.

Said Dorothy Parady, 59 Wards Hill Road, “It could be a real threat, I’m a wreck.”

Plan-It Recycling material, as seen from Gorham Industrial
Parkway, could eventually be trucked to the long-closed Gorham
landfill. (Staff photo by Robert Lowell)

Comments are no longer available on this story