WINDHAM – Windham and Raymond voters head to the polls Tuesday, June 14, to determine the fate of the $37.96 million RSU 14 school budget.
While school officials say the proposed budget is about the same as 2008-2009 school budget, due to further decreases in state and federal subsidies, local taxpayers will see a total 2.75 percent increase if the budget passes, with Windham residents paying more than Raymond due to subsidy calculations.
Windham taxpayers, if the budget passes, can expect to see an increase of 51.46 per thousand of valuation, meaning a taxpayer who owns a $200,000 home would see a $103 increase on their property tax bill for school spending. In Raymond, property taxpayers would see a decrease of 23.4 per thousand of valuation, with a $200,000 home seeing a tax cut of about $47. Both towns’ municipal budgets are flat-funded this year.
According to Assistant Superintendent Donn Davis, the district is projecting $13.8 million in federal and state subsidy next year, down $188,000 from this year. Davis said the district has lost $2 million in the past three years as local property values and enrollment figures – two determining factors for subsidy – outpace other Maine towns. Windham-Raymond is the state’s seventh-largest school district, with 3,500 students.
After working through Superintendent Sandy Prince’s proposed budget submitted in March that called for a 3.1 percent increase, RSU 14 school board members were able to whittle the increase to 2.75 percent, which Chairman Mike Duffy said is a “very fair budget.”
“It’s still lower than the budgets of the two towns prior to consolidation,” he said, “so we’re asking for lower money but the way the school funding is from the state, it comes out higher unfortunately.”
Longtime board member Toby Pennels said he would have liked to see a lower tax increase for Windham residents but, he said, “from the beginning I recognized that an attempt to not raise community taxes was going to be challenging and unfortunately the budget we approved, if blessed by the community at the polls, will raise taxes in Windham. We were able to hold the line in Raymond.”
“I’ve never subscribed to the solution of just throwing money at the budget and I do believe our deliberative process thoroughly examines the tough questions,” Pennels said. “Could we do better? I think there’s always room to improve.”
While the district has cut 64 positions in the last few years, the school board-approved budget would cut 2.3 positions. Former Raymond Superintendent Sandie Caldwell’s part-time administrative position has been cut. A total of 1.2 teaching positions (including a .8 position teaching family consumer science and pieces of several other teaching positions) were cut as well. And a half-time support staff position at Manchester Elementary School was cut.
With an average per pupil cost of $8,976, the district ranks 151st out of 229 school districts in the state for per pupil costs. The state average is $9,832.
“This year, there weren’t as many cuts to staff, but after cutting 65 positions in recent years, there’s not too much left to cut out,” Duffy said.
Pennels said the cost to educate Raymond students is more costly mainly due to lower enrollments. Both Raymond Elementary School and Jordan Small Middle School operate at half-capacity, whereas all of Windham’s schools operate at capacity. The district attempted to close Jordan Small Middle School, but with minimal forecasted savings and the anticipated expense of retrofitting Raymond Elementary to handle the influx of middle-school students, the proposal met up against opposition from Raymond parents through a course of public meetings late last year.
“Something I have expressed publicly is that I am not happy that the cost per child to educate our students in Raymond is comparatively out of whack with our sister schools here in Windham,” Pennels said. “I think the RSU merger was a good fit, and I still do, and I hold no illusions that our smaller schools in Raymond will be more expensive to operate. However, we absolutely need to do better.”
In addition to voting on the school budget next Tuesday, Windham and Raymond voters will also see a question asking whether they approve transferring $400,000 from the undesignated fund balance (surplus) into a capital reserve account.
According to Duffy, the school board wants to spend the amount carried over from this year’s budget on capital improvements, namely a new heating and air conditioning system at the Windham Middle School and improvements to the traffic patterns at Windham Primary School.
Comments are no longer available on this story