SCARBOROUGH – Despite concerns over how it would be enforced, the Scarborough Town Council last week moved forward with an ordinance that would ban the use of tobacco products at town beaches.
The council voted 4 to 1, with Ron Ahlquist dissenting, to place the proposed ordinance before a March 16 public hearing. Councilors Carol Rancourt and Karen D’Andrea were absent from the meeting.
As proposed, the ordinance would ban the use of tobacco on town beaches, except in designated areas, as well as on public property within 25 feet of a public beach.
While a couple of residents spoke in favor of the proposed ban, citing health benefits, some councilors, including Chairwoman Judy Roy, worried about whether the ordinance would be effective in stopping smoking.
“In my opinion,” she said last week prior to the meeting, “it is going to be another ordinance that will be difficult to enforce.”
Councilor Richard Sullivan said he understands the thought behind banning smoking, but questioned why using other tobacco products at the beach was included.
“I am a little curious about how this came to be,” he said of the ordinance including all tobacco products. “I think a lot of people will look at this ordinance as regulating behavior.”
Ahlquist, a park ranger at Crescent Beach State Park, where smoking was recently banned, said he, too, is concerned about the enforcement of the ordinance.
“I support this ordinance,” he said. “I think it is a good idea, but my concern is how do you enforce it.”
He said a smoking ban can more easily be enforced at state parks because the state has staff to monitor the park, something the public beaches in Scarborough can’t afford.
“We still have people trying to smoke (in the state parks) and get away with it,” he said. “I am real hesitant passing something we can’t enforce.”
Councilors brought up several ways that the ordinance could be enforced, including by volunteers, the Volunteers In Policing group or the police department, although Ahlquist said he doesn’t want the police department to get inundated with phone calls.
Sometimes peer pressure, D’Andrea noted in an interview prior to the meeting, is all that is needed to enforce such an ordinance. Education, Ahlquist said, also goes a long way toward getting people to abide by the ordinance.
Ahlquist tried unsuccessfully to amend the order to delay the public hearing and return the ordinance to the Ordinance Committee so the group could address the enforceability concerns.
Councilor Jessica Holbrook, who joined Ahlquist in voting to return the idea to the Ordinance Committee, argued that the council would perhaps be better passing the ban as a non-binding resolution rather than an ordinance.
Two councilors, D’Andrea and Mike Wood, said they favored giving the ordinance an opportunity to work.
“I am very supportive of this,” D’Andrea said early last week, prior to the meeting. “I think it is a wonderful idea.”
Two Scarborough mothers who spoke at the meeting also applauded the idea.
“I am supportive of banning smoking on the beach,” said Stephanie Perry. “As we know we are very fortunate to have access to such beautiful beaches.”
Her support for the measure, however, was not just about preserving the beauty of the beaches.
“I have a son who is asthmatic and it is detrimental if he is by secondhand smoke,” said Perry. “I am hoping you are considering this as a way of making this a safer environment for the children of Scarborough.”
Tina Pettingill, a Scarborough resident and executive director of the Maine Public Health Association, said any amount of secondhand smoke is dangerous to people, especially those with chronic breathing and heart issues.
Pettingill, who came to the meeting with her daughters Grace and Avery, said the notion that the impact of secondhand smoke is not as severe outdoors as it is indoors is faulty.
“We have good data that shows outdoor exposure, depending where the person is compared to the smoker, those levels can be as dangerous as the levels of being indoors,” she said.
The idea for the ordinance came from Black Point Road resident Sharman Kivatisky, who at a council meeting last September suggested the town follow the state’s lead and ban smoking at beaches.
She told councilors at the time cigarettes are not only a health concern for people, but for animals and the environment, as well.
“People tend to throw their (cigarette) butts right in the sand,” she said. “They are not biodegradable and are a hazard to the wildlife.”
According to Peter Slovinsky, a member of the Northern New England Chapter of Surfriders International, which has organized beach cleanups all over southern Maine in recent years, cigarette butts are the No. 1 piece of litter found at beaches.
In fact, during a one-hour cleanup of Pine Point Beach during Maine Coast Week last summer, Slovinsky and his team of volunteers picked up around 1,000 cigarette butts.
Comments are no longer available on this story