3 min read

PORTLAND – The price of energy and the mix of energy sources enjoyed by Maine residents today are, to a large extent, the result of the energy policies of Maine governors over the past 30 years. These policies have been driven both by the political approaches of these governors and the crises to which they were required to respond. Today, Maine faces significant challenges relating to the high cost of energy, climate change, jobs and national security.

The next governor will have three critical energy issues waiting on the desk when he or she takes office: the cost of energy, the need to address renewable energy objectives, and the opportunity to create jobs in the energy sector.

Energy costs have risen in recent years for a number of reasons, many of which are beyond the control of the governor. However, strategies do exist to address cost in either the short or long term.

Current policy favors additional development of renewable electricity. Many renewable technologies cost more than traditional sources of electricity. State government has options that could offset some of the difference, such as accepting Canadian renewables, amending renewable requirements, or supporting lower-cost technologies that are difficult to license.

Maine’s natural resources provide a significant opportunity for the creation of energy-related jobs. However, many technologies require financial assistance to be fully developed. The next governor must consider whether and how to subsidize such development.

At the recent gubernatorial forum hosted by E2Tech, the Environmental & Energy Technology Council of Maine, the candidates — except Kevin Scott, who could not attend — agreed that the state must balance challenges presented by the impact of high energy costs, the desire to create jobs, and goals related to climate change. However, the forum demonstrated clear differences in the goals and approaches advocated by each candidate.

Advertisement

Democrat Libby Mitchell emphasized the development of offshore wind power and the enhancement of environmental regulation. She expressed concern about the visual impact of wind projects on mountains. She opposes a long-term power deal with Quebec, like Vermont has, because it would interfere with the development of local renewable generation. She is open to additional large-scale electric transmission to deliver Maine renewables or Canadian power. Finally, Mitchell opposes any restructuring of the Board of Environmental Protection or the Land Use Regulation Commission, and would provide additional resources to those agencies.

Republican Paul LePage stressed reducing cost as his overriding energy goal. He proposed looking at all options — renewables, natural gas, Canadian, nuclear and others — and ranking them based on cost and environmental impact to develop state policy. He supports continued research into wind and solar power. He would support a long-term deal with Quebec if it would lower the cost of energy to Maine consumers. He would also seek to expand the availability of natural gas for industry and heating, and protect existing hydroelectric dams. LePage would consider significant restructuring of BEP and LURC.

Independent Eliot Cutler proposed the creation of a Maine Energy Finance Authority to reduce costs and support the development of new infrastructure, including renewable generation, natural gas pipelines to serve Maine communities, and energy conservation projects. He believes that the state should look at multiple renewable technologies and that it should rely on federal assistance to support research and development for offshore wind. Cutler would support a long-term deal with Quebec, but only on favorable terms. He suggested developing alternatives before negotiating. He supports the current environmental licensing standards administered by BEP and LURC, but is concerned about delays in their processes.

Independent Shawn Moody stated that he would focus on the development of renewable energy and energy conservation. He offered specific proposals regarding income tax incentives for conservation and increasing efficiency at existing generators. Moody supports the state’s existing wind power goals. He does not favor entering into a long-term agreement with Quebec for energy supply because doing so would interfere with achievement of Maine’s long-term energy goals. Moody favors exempting smaller businesses from some BEP and LURC regulations and processes.

Regardless of which candidate wins the election on Nov. 2, the next governor will need work with the Legislature, residents and business to craft an effective energy policy. He or she will have to work quickly to reconcile campaign proposals with the energy issues they’ll face when they take office in January.

 

– Special to The Press Herald

 

Comments are no longer available on this story