4 min read

Darwin’s theory of evolution was not about the survival of the fittest but survival of the most adaptable to environmental change. It seems Maine residents and businesses have adapted to an ever-lower standard of living rather than going about the work of changing their economic environment.

Public policy plays a significant role in that equation. That’s one reason I’m anxious to see what voters will do on Election Day.

Will they send a fresh crop of change agents or return the same kind of people to Augusta who got us here in the first place? That does not mean a Democratic or Republican majority. It means electing the right people for the job.

These thoughts are prompted by two recent national rankings of states, one that measures the business climate and the other that measures levels of personal well-being.

The results suggest that Maine people may be Darwinian adapters rather than economic change agents.

Last week, Forbes.com released its fifth annual Best States for Business rankings. Maine moved from 10th-worst among the 50 states in 2008 to dead last. The business publication noted, “Growth prospects in Maine have deteriorated relative to the rest of the country. Job growth is expected to increase 1.3 percent annually over the next five years – one of the worst forecasts in the country.”

Advertisement

Despite that dire news, another state ranking suggests that Maine people are feeling OK about their personal situation. The Gallup-Healthways Well-Being Index (www.wellbeingindex.com) ranked Maine 16th in the nation. The index measures life evaluation, emotional health, physical health, healthy behavior, work environment and basic access to necessities crucial to a positive sense of well-being.

According to the Well-Being Index, survey respondents from Maine are largely satisfied with their standard of living. That satisfaction actually grew while the recession worsened from 2008 to 2009. In addition, Maine residents showed the greatest increase in optimism in the nation when considering their prospects for the future.

Maine’s poor-but-happy situation stands in stark contrast to Utah, which ascended from second place a year ago to this year’s top spot in the Forbes rankings and captured the No. 2 spot on the Well-Being Index. Utah is both prosperous and happy.

Forbes.com said Utah’s economic distinction is no fluke. The state has “energy costs 35 percent below the national average, an educated labor force – with 90 percent of residents holding a high school diploma (and 29 percent a college degree), a great quality of life with low poverty rates, a healthy populace and ample recreational opportunities.

Utah boasts a AAA debt rating from Moody’s, S&P and Fitch. Earlier this year Forbes crowned Utah the country’s most fiscally fit state government.”

The state’s governor, Gary Herbert, amplified the message of success by saying, “We have a fiscally conservative government where we are trying to keep government off your backs and out of your wallet. We want the free market to do what it does best. We want to make sure we don’t have any nonsensical regulations that inhibit the private sector from expanding and having a profitable bottom line.”

Advertisement

Capital investment goes where it is welcome, and Utah has made itself the welcome mat of America when it comes to economic health.

tah’s economy may one day come tumbling down but, for the time being, its prosperity and happiness outpace the country.

An article in the Wall Street Journal noted that in 1974, economist Richard Easterlin argued “that individuals who got richer quickly acclimated to their new circumstances, and within a short time were no happier than before.”

The same article quotes Wharton School of Business economist Betsey Stevenson saying more recently, “We see very strong relationships” between wealth and happiness. “There’s no evidence of satiation, this idea that it flattens out over time.

“If I take any country regardless of whether it’s rich or poor, and increase its income by 10 percent, those countries are going to have the same increase in happiness.”

It would be nice for Maine people to find out if wealth and happiness go hand-in-hand.

If there’s a lesson in the two national rankings, it’s that at least one state has demonstrated that it can have a robust economy without sacrificing its sense of personal well-being. If Maine’s public policy and political leadership could mimic Utah’s, perhaps we at least could be claiming bragging rights as the “most improved” in just a matter of years.

What do you think and what are you willing to do about it?

Tony Payne is a lifelong resident of Maine who is active in business, civic and political affairs. He may be reached at:
tpayne@midmaine.com

 

Comments are no longer available on this story