SCARBOROUGH – With another tight budget expected for next school year and the possibility of again asking voters to fund the construction of a new intermediate school, there are a number of hot-button issues before the Scarborough Board of Education.
Three people, incumbent John Cole and challengers Bill Armishaw and Aymie Hardesty, are hoping to claim one of two open seats on the board to help steer Scarborough schools. Current school board Chairman Brian Dell’ Olio has chosen to run for a seat in the Maine Legislature representing District 128, rather than another term on the school board.
Armishaw and Cole were among local candidates for Town Council and school board who spoke at a Candidates Night on Oct. 14, in which members of the media posed questions. The event was sponsored by the Scarborough Chamber of Commerce.
Hardesty could not make the event, but later answered the questions in an email interview with the Current.
There is no doubt in Cole’s mind that budgeting for next school year is going to be as difficult, if not worse, than the last budget cycle.
“It is not fun,” he said. “It is challenging, that’s for sure. All in all, I think we’ll see a repeat next year, if not tougher.”
Last year, because of a tight budget, the district was forced to cut the equivalent of 30 positions.
“We are probably going to have to make a lot of tough decisions, but I’d rather not see teachers or staff cut,” Armishaw said, adding he would also like to see the math and science department budgets untouched.
Cole agreed, saying the district and the board have to continue looking at ways to keep from eliminating teachers and programming.
Cole said he predicts because of the budget, the district may have no choice but to impose higher user fees, cut more positions and ask taxpayers to dig a little deeper to fund the school budgets.
“We will have to work closely with the Town Council,” Cole said. “Thank goodness we have councilors who understand the importance of education.”
Hardesty said raising taxes to fund the school budget might be the only way to go.
“I will probably get ousted for this but I would rather ask for more taxes, or juggle staff rather than fire them,” she said. “I’m a registered Republican and have always been against raising taxes, but we have to start thinking of the greater good and the good of the community. I wish we could find a way to leave senior citizens’ taxes alone and citizens with income under the poverty level, or some ratio thereof.”
As a result of some difficult choices over the years, Armishaw, Cole and Hardesty feel funding is lacking in a number of school departments.
One of those areas, Cole said, is technology – the field he works in. He said because of this, students are not gaining the skills they need to be successful in either college or in the workforce.
“I am afraid we may have a population of kids who are falling into that group,” he said.
Dwindling budgets, he said, have also lead to larger class sizes, something he wants to reverse in the younger grades.
Armishaw agreed smaller class sizes would improve early instruction. He said students who come from smaller classes in kindergarten, first, second and third grades tend to score higher on the SATs in high school.
Hardesty said the language department is among those lacking due to not enough funding. She said growing up in Skowhegan she was offered German, Latin, French, Italian and Spanish. Currently Scarborough High School offers French, Spanish and Latin. Scarborough Middle School and Wentworth Intermediate School offer both French and Spanish.
The athletics department is also suffering, Hardesty said.
She said she doesn’t feel imposing fees for students to participate in extracurricular activities was the right way to go, especially for those with multiple children in the system.
“We are excluding many children by having to implement the sports and activity fee,” she said. “Although I know this is a sign of the times for now, and a necessary measure in order to keep total activities from being cut, I worry that many won’t even sign up because they would never file the paperwork to ask for help – too embarrassing in this town.”
If things are cut from the budget due to funding, Hardesty said, she hoped the cuts would not be permanent.
“I know we need to work to find solutions in tough times,” Hardesty said. “I only hope that if we cut something now, it can be reinstated later and not lost.”
Outside of the budget, the school board will have a number of important decisions to make about the future of the schools, among them finding a permanent fix to the problems at Wentworth Intermediate School and finding a permanent replacement for David Doyle, who retired as superintendent earlier this month.
The need for a new or updated Wentworth school, is not a new concept in town. In 2006, a $55 million bond that included $38.3 million to rebuild Wentworth was overwhelmingly rejected by voters. The need for a new school has resurfaced after this summer, when part of the facility was discovered to be contaminated with asbestos, a material used in construction known to be a carcinogen. There have also been concerns addressed about levels of mold and radon.
“For many years Wentworth has been on the radar for the community, but it has really come up in the past few months,” Cole said. “Given the circumstances, they did an admirable job,” he said of the school administration’s work mitigating the situation. “Could they have done a better job? Yes.”
Hardesty was more critical of the administration’s response to the situation, especially the initial recommendation to close the windows where the asbestos was found, even during the heat early in the school year.
“I feel that our children should have been sent home early (or classes canceled) on those first few days of school when temps were over 90 degrees and humid,” said Hardesty. “We could have sent all those children home with lunch, thus counting as a full day, and had the buses back for the high school. If we have snow days, why can’t we have oppressive heat and unhealthy air days? That being said, the board’s response, I believe, was due to the fact that the administration has not always informed the board of real issues and complaints. The administration has done a great job of keeping issues from the board. As a board member, I would work to get a process in place where such information could not be hidden,” she said, adding, “transparency is key in this process.”
Cole said he could support the idea of constructing a new, improved school, if that was ultimately what was recommended.
“I will support whatever the building committee comes up with as long as it is a responsible request,” Cole added. “I want to see the bare essentials of a building. The feedback I get is that all people want is a good, basic infrastructure with no frills that is easy to maintain.”
Hardesty, too, said she would support bonding a new school.
“I do support a bond for a new school, but do not believe it needs all the ‘bells and whistles’ and should not be tied to any other project,” she said.
Armishaw said other solutions to fix the asbestos and mold problems in the school should be examined before bonding for a new school. Such solution could be to either shift children to other classrooms or perhaps look into other school buildings to move classrooms into.
“A timely decision has not been made and people are suffering because of it,” he said.
Long term, he said, administrators should consider constructing a simple school that could be set up for any grade level, not just elementary, intermediate, or middle school.
“There are some solutions out there and they should be looked at instead of a bond,” he said.
In terms of finding a new leader for the school district to replace Doyle, Cole said he is looking for someone who is fiscally responsible with a track record of success. Assistant Superintendent Joanne Sizemore is expected to take over in the interim as the board and district look for a permanent replacement.
“I want a visionary. I want someone who is not just a good communicator, but an excellent communicator,” he said adding he also wants someone who can engage students and motivate staff, teachers, residents and students.
After spending 20 years in the Marine Corp, Armishaw said, the most important trait in a superintendent is leadership skills.
“We need someone strong,” he said, “to bring students to the point where they become good citizens.”
Hardesty said while she supports promoting from within, perhaps in this case, finding someone who can bring a fresh approach and new ideas is the best way to go in hiring a new superintendent.
“I’m not against looking at candidates from within, but strongly feel that we as a community should look at new ideas and faces, as well,” she said. “I would promote the hiring of someone who would encourage staff and educators to be a better part of the process. Perhaps someone who would more readily put citizen concerns on agendas and be more willing to be a true go-between of the staff and school board.”
Election
Bill Armishaw
John Cole
Comments are no longer available on this story