WINDHAM – Windham High School juniors got the chance Tuesday to
see the judicial branch of government in action with a visit from
the Maine Supreme Judicial Court.
WINDHAM – Putting away their schoolbooks for a more experiential form of learning, Windham High School juniors got the chance Tuesday to see the judicial branch of government in action.
On the invitation of Windham’s legislative delegation – Sen. Bill Diamond, and Reps. Mark Bryant and Gary Plummer – the Maine Supreme Judicial Court, the state’s highest court, led by Chief Justice Leigh Saufley, held its session on the stage in the school’s auditorium.
“We have a very unique learning experience today,” Deb McAfee briefed students prior to the 9 a.m. start time. “Very few schools have been selected to observe this, and certainly this is a great learning experience for you take back into your history classes or just for you to be able to see how our government works, how our judicial system works.”
With that, students observed three appeals cases, the first of which was a manslaughter appeal that generated thoughtful questions from students. The other two involved a vehicular manslaughter appeal and a commercial driver’s license suspension appeal.
In the first appeal, students observed defense attorney Sarah Churchill argue on behalf of her convicted client, York resident Richard Dalli. Churchill was appealing what she described as too stiff a sentence against her client, who was found guilty earlier this year and sentenced to 30 years in prison, with all but 20 years suspended, for stabbing fellow York resident Robert Wheeler on Sept. 2, 2008. Churchill argued that the sentencing judge failed to take into account similar cases that resulted in more lenient sentences, when determining Dalli’s sentence.
After Churchill’s 15 minutes of lodging her appeal, the state’s prosecuting attorney, Assistant Attorney General Donald Macomber, took 15 minutes arguing for the sentence, saying it was appropriate given the severity of the crime. Speaking amongst themselves and with the two attorneys, the justices spent a total of 30 minutes discussing the pros and cons of the sentence – originally handed down by a York County Superior Court judge – before recessing.
The court won’t issue a decision for several months. But while the justices were offstage, Macomber and Churchill answered questions from students.
The most pointed question came from student Joshua Ryan, who asked why the state doesn’t have a sentencing database that justices and judges could refer to when determining appropriate sentences.
“Why isn’t there a database already,” Ryan asked. “I feel like that would be an obvious solution to the problem.”
Churchill said it was a question of available funding.
“The court probably would like to but they don’t have the money to create one,” he told the students.
The event’s moderator, attorney Cathy Connor, then invited Diamond, chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee, which would fund such a database, to comment.
“That is a great question,” Diamond said. “We need to get this sort of information to the legislative process. I would guess most legislators don’t realize what the situation is right now. It hasn’t been brought to their attention. This will bring it to their attention. Believe me.
“One of the good things about having this event today is to get new ideas and to hear new things that we should be working on, and this is one of them. So, it’s a great question, great issue, and I think we need to start dealing with it.”
The event was considered a success by one of its main organizers, social studies teacher Phil Rossetti.
“You never know what the reaction of kids will be to an event like this, but it seems based on the questions, we’ve got some solid thinking going on and some great answers the people are giving to the kids,” he said.
Rossetti most appreciated the hands-on nature of the event. “It’s exciting, it’s an opportunity for kids to see what happens. We talk about all these civic lessons, but it’s nice for them to be able to apply what we’ve been talking about in a real-life setting,” he said. “It’s just a great opportunity for kids to see the law in action.”
The state’s lead prosecutor against Dalli, Lisa Marchese, was also in attendance and was duly impressed by the Windham students.
“I think having a law court argument at a high school is a fabulous experience for everyone, both a learning experience for the kids and a great opportunity for the community to see what the attorney general’s office, the court, defense attorneys, what everyone does,” Marchese said.
And as would be the case in any normal courtroom-based appeal, family members of the victim, in this case John Wheeler, were also in attendance. After the appeal had been heard, the family was gracious in their comments on the process, which was more public than they were expecting.
“I think it’s good for kids to get exposure to the legal system,” said Robert Wheeler, son of John Wheeler.
Robert Wheeler, a South Paris resident who also spoke briefly during the appeal hearing, said he thought “kids weren’t paying attention at first but after a while it seemed some of them really were. I was impressed by it. I was a little confused why it was here at first, but then I realized it was a demonstration.”
Wheeler’s mother, Oxford resident Kelley Thurston, said of the proceeding, “I think that as far as it being done here (at Windham High School), there’s less people in the courtroom, so at least having it done here, there’s that many more people taking something away from this. At least here, there’s something to be learned. It’s not just a dry courtroom.”
The Maine Supreme Judicial Court visited Windham High School on Tuesday to give students an up-close look at how the law works in the state. Before the first hearing, the crowd and justices applauded as Chief Justice Leigh Saufley acknowledged the high school staff who helped make the visit possible. (Photos by Rich Obrey)
Windham High junior T. D. O’Brien was one of several students who took the opportunity to question the attorneys arguing appeals before the Maine Supreme Judicial Court. (Photo by Rich Obrey)
Comments are no longer available on this story