WINDHAM – A Cumberland County Superior Court judge has dismissed one of the three counts against Rent-A-Husband owner and former Windham Town Councilor Kaile Warren.
Justice Thomas Warren ruled Tuesday that Warren can’t be tried on the sale of unregistered securities for Rent-A-Husband, since he wasn’t aware the securities were not properly registered under Maine law regarding sale of investments.
However, in his nine-page ruling, the judge upheld the two other counts against Warren, namely theft by deception and securities fraud.
Warren was indicted in December 2009 on three counts of securities-related fraud. Warren sold hundreds of promissory notes and other investments in Rent-A-Husband. Investors accuse Warren of luring investments by misrepresenting the health of the company.
Warren said Wednesday he is “ecstatic” with the judge’s dismissal of the count.
“This is a huge win, I couldn’t be happier. And we look forward to aggressively pursuing the other two counts,” Warren said.
Warren maintains his overall innocence and has maintained that his former law firm, Preti Flaherty, incorrectly advised him as to the sale of investments, namely promissory notes, in his national handyman business, Rent-A-Husband, a charge the law firm has denied.
The state’s prosecutor, Michael Colleran, said Wednesday the judge’s ruling only affected a minor part of the state’s case and that the state is looking forward to a trial, which could likely start in January.
“We are pleased that the court disagreed with Mr. Warren on the felony theft and fraud charges, and we are prepared to go forward on those charges,” Colleran said. “The ruling on the less serious charge of sale of unregistered securities is an interpretation of law, not of fact, and is an interpretation with which we respectfully disagree.”
Kaile Warren believes that the judge would have thrown out the other two counts if he were allowed to read testimony from the grand jury that indicted Warren based on information provided by Colleran last December. Warren insists Colleran misled and misinformed the grand jury as to securities law.
“Prosecutorial misconduct behind closed doors with a grand jury makes a despicable mockery of justice in our justice system. I feel sorry for the grand jury members who indicted an innocent person with their decision. The issue is not with grand jury members, as I believe they try hard to reach the right decision. It is the questionable knowledge and morals of the prosecutor who guided them, that led to this reprehensible injustice,” Warren said in a statement.
In his ruling, Justice Warren explained that since grand jury testimony is secret, he was bound to allow those counts to proceed to trial.
Colleran declined to respond to Kaile Warren’s charges that he misled the grand jury.
“The court specifically declined Mr. Warren’s request to review the grand jury proceedings, and I am prohibited by court rule from discussing those proceedings,” he said Wednesday.
Warren now faces a maximum sentence of 10 years for theft by deception and five years for securities fraud.
Comments are no longer available on this story