3 min read

SOUTH PORTLAND – While there is no question among city councilors that South Portland needs a new high school to replace the current facility, how much the city can afford – and is willing – to spend has been a contentious topic.

Before the council currently is a $47.26 million plan to rehabilitate 115,000 square feet of the existing infrastructure and construct 170,000 square feet of new space. At a workshop Monday for a presentation about the proposed plan, which is designed by Auburn-based Harriman Architects and Engineers, the council learned how the project compares with construction at other local high schools.

Daniel Cecil, a principal with Harriman, said the cost of the project can be looked at two ways, in terms of cost per square foot or cost per student.

With a projection of 1,100 students, the proposed project would spend just over $42,963 per student. With the alternate funding sources factored in, that number could be as low as $40,000 per student.

As comparison, Cecil said, the $34.9 million Biddeford High School project, also a Harriman project, results in $34,915 per student.

Cecil said the cost of the South Portland project is nearly $12 million more than the cost to rehab Biddeford High School, a school of similar size, because more new construction is needed. Biddeford’s project includes more renovations because the infrastructure is in better shape, he said. New construction can cost as much as $160 per square foot versus the $40 to $100 per square foot to simply renovate, he said.

Advertisement

The renovation plan calls for keeping the original part of the school while tearing down and replacing the school’s annex, which is in poor condition, with new classroom space. The construction plan envisions a 285,000-square-foot school, resulting in roughly 259 square feet per student. Biddeford High School affords 248 square feet per student and Scarborough High School has 242 square feet per student.

Superintendent Suzanne Godin said the square footage in South Portland is higher because of the layout of the high school campus, which includes three anchors, the auditorium, gymnasium and the original part of the high school.

Cecil said South Portland needs a larger school than nearby communities because its graduation requirements mandate more teaching and classroom space. Graduates in South Portland are required to complete 24 credit hours. In Scarborough High School, for example, 21 credit hours are needed for graduation, he said. In Biddeford, 16 are needed.

Increased costs also stem from making the school facility more handicapped accessible and LEED (Leader of Energy and Environmental Design) certified, which adds $1.5 million to theprice tag. The money, proponents argue, would be recouped in the form of better efficiency and lower energy costs.

Councilor Rosemarie DeAngelis, a longtime educator and an instructor at Southern Maine Community College, said she felt the project includes pieces that are not necessary.

“What concerns me,” she said, “is there’s the ideal, there’s the desire and then there is reality, what is really needed.”

Advertisement

The project, however, is not just designed for today’s educational needs, but the needs of the school system 25 or 50 years down the road, Godin said

In this regard, she said, the project is being designed with an enrollment of 1,100 in mind. According to projections for the next 10 years, enrollment will continue to grow every year and climb to more than1,000 students the last three years of the projected period.

Godin said the district has used the projections for a number of years and had been off only three or four students from the actual total.

Councilor Patti Smith suggested easing the burden on taxpayers by tapping into other, private funding sources such as fundraising.

Godin said the school department does not have the resources to do that, but would support individuals or a group undertaking such an effort.

“Its potentially something that could be worthwhile, even if it was for only a million or two. It is nothing to sneeze at,” Smith said.

The City Council will revisit the topic again at its next workshop on Monday, Aug. 9. Outside of the City Council’s review of the project, an independent review of Harriman’s proposal is currently under way.

The council has made examining the high school project its top priority this year, followed by looking into a new Department of Public Works facility and new City Hall.

Comments are no longer available on this story