RAYMOND–A Raymond attorney is awaiting discipline from the Maine Supreme Judicial Court for professional misconduct, which could result in his disbarment.
Justice Jon Levy has yet to issue sanctions against Miklos Pongratz, whom Levy found guilty in April of propositioning a client for sexual relations, as well as putting conditions on the return of a client’s legal file.
Depending on what Levy imposes as sanctions, Pongratz, who has a solo practice in Raymond on Route 302, could face disbarment. A more likely result, according to Scott Davis, who prosecuted the case against Pongratz on behalf of the Maine Board of Overseers of the Bar, would be a short-term suspension. Davis said the state is seeking a two-month suspension.
“There would be no jail sentence. It’s a civil matter,” Davis said. “We’ve made a proposal for punishment, and we’re just waiting on Justice Levy to issue his ruling.”
While punishment is still pending, according to court documents issued April 8, Levy has already found in favor of Pongratz’ former client, Darcie Bolduc of Oxford. She is represented by Brunswick lawyer Tom Bell, who did not return phone calls seeking comment.
According to information in a five-page “findings of fact and conclusions of law” written by Levy, Pongratz was representing Bolduc for a family matter in Bridgton District Court in the fall of 2007. After a second mediation session on Nov. 5, 2007, Pongratz invited Bolduc to a Bridgton diner and then a bar in Gray. After breakfast at the Bridgton diner, Pongratz and Bolduc traveled in separate vehicles to Pongratz’s office in Raymond before driving together in Pongratz’ truck to the bar in Gray, where they each drank two beers.
According to documents, Pongratz put his hand on Bolduc’s thigh at the Bridgton diner and then took a photograph of Bolduc’s buttocks at the bar with his cell phone. He then propositioned Bolduc on the drive back to Raymond.
“During the ride from Gray to Raymond, Pongratz again expressed to Bolduc that he was attracted to her, and he proposed that they go to his home to have sex,” Levy concluded. “Pongratz told Bolduc that if she wanted to have sex with him, ‘that would be fine.’ She responded, ‘You’re my lawyer, you’re not supposed to talk like this.’ Having refused Pongratz’s invitation, Bolduc left for home in her own car as soon as they arrived in Raymond. The day’s events left Bolduc confused and shaken.”
On advice from his lawyer, Pongratz, who became a member of the Maine bar in 2004, had no comment.
Levy cleared Pongratz of the most serious allegation, however, a charge made by Bolduc that Pongratz offered to forgive her legal fees, which amounted to $2,200, in exchange for sex. Levy found there wasn’t enough substantive evidence to prove that charge.
Levy wrote in his summary: “Pongratz’s proposal of a quid pro quo of sex in exchange for the forgiveness of legal fees is the most serious professional misconduct alleged by the Board … The most probative and reliable evidence regarding this critical fact is Bolduc’s testimony, under oath, that she could not recall what Pongratz said at the diner. The Court concludes that the allegation of a quid pro quo has not been proven by a preponderance of the evidence.”
Davis would not comment on Levy’s determination regarding the state’s most serious allegation.
Pongratz also faces punishment on the other count of withholding Bolduc’s client record until she agreed in writing to a payment schedule. According to court documents, Bolduc ceased using Pongratz’ services after the events of Nov. 5, 2007, and wished to enlist the services of another lawyer, Bell. Since Bolduc owed Pongratz $2,200 for his services at Bridgton District Court, Pongratz required Bolduc to come to his office to sign a payment plan agreement before he would give her back her client file. According to state law, lawyers cannot withhold a client file based on nonpayment.
Comments are no longer available on this story