SCARBOROUGH – By just 10 votes, Scarborough voters on Tuesday rejected the new $34.9 million 2010-2011 school budget.
The vote was 493 voters against the budget and 483 in favor of it.
While some voters – 387 – said the budget was too high, a majority – or 490 voters – said it was too low.
At the May 11 referendum, Scarborough voters also gave a strong indication they want to continue voting on the school budget each year at the polls. They voted 774 to 206 on a question asking if they favored continuing to hold such public votes.
The number of residents voting in the special election – less than 1,000 – represented only a small fraction of Scarborough’s active 14,733 registered voters.
The school budget now will go back to the Board of Education and Town Council for reconsideration. The council sets the bottom line on the school budget.
The council also will have to vote on when to send the reconsidered school budget back to voters. Possible dates were still under discussion around noon on Wednesday, said Town Manager Tom Hall. However, he said it’s possible the school budget validation vote would be held the day of the upcoming primary election on June 8.
Brian Dell’Olio, chairman of the school board, said on Wednesday that the board will meet on Monday, May 17, to discuss the school budget. The meeting will take place at 3:30 p.m. in the council chambers at Town Hall, he said.
“The board is going to discuss options in terms of recommendations back to the Town Council (regarding the school budget),” Dell’Olio said.
He said he believes that the close vote shows the voters had as hard a time deciding on the school budget as elected officials did while crafting a budget this year while accounting for drastic revenue cutbacks in the economic recession.
“It kind of shows me they struggled too,” Dell’Olio said of voters.
The $34.9 million school operating budget proposal was part of the new 2010-2011 $64.8 million town budget the Town Council approved May 5.
The town budget the council approved included the school budget and the municipal budget of $27.9 million, as well nearly $2 million in taxes that Scarborough must pay to Cumberland County.
A 2007 state law makes the school portion of the budget subject to voter approval.
The total town budget would have boosted the current tax rate of $12.15 per $1,000 of assessed property value by 48 cents to $12.63, an increase of 3.95 percent.
The budget would have increased the annual tax bill of a $300,000 home by $144.
The municipal part of the budget accounts for 17 cents of that tax rate increase, county taxes represent a 1-cent increase this year, and the school budget would have accounted for 30 cents of the 48-cent tax rate increase.
Even though the municipal and school budgets boosted taxes, they still contained cuts. That’s because of drastic reductions in revenues – such as a 19 percent decrease in state education aid to Scarborough.
The school budget eliminated the equivalent of about 30 full-time school jobs of teachers and other staff. It also called for raising $200,000 in new revenues by imposing fees on students for extracurricular activities. Details on the fee schedule still would need to be worked out.
Dell’Olio said that while a majority of the voters said the budget was too low, no dollar figure was associated with that vote. He said the challenge now for school board members and the council is to figure out a budget bottom line that voters will accept.
Further complicating the matter is that so few residents voted on the budget. “It is a very limited sample of Scarborough citizens,” Dell’Olio said.
The previous two budget validation votes in Scarborough also had a similar low turnout.
Hall said that if the budget validation vote is held on the date of the June 8 primary election, when more voters typically go to the polls, those voters might feel differently about the school budget.
Hall said Tuesday’s vote “really puts us into a tailspin trying to understand what the electorate is saying.”
He said the council at its regular meeting on Wednesday, May 20, is expected to schedule dates for a first reading vote on a new school budget, a public hearing and then a second reading vote. Hall said it’s possible the council could schedule the public hearing to coincide with the second reading vote.
The total town budget is slated to take effect on July 1.
Comments are no longer available on this story