4 min read

WESTBROOK–Westbrook will forge ahead with the cleanup of its long-troubled fire department, despite a state arbitration board’s decision to reinstate a firefighter who was fired in December.

“It’s a setback, but it’s not insurmountable,” Mayor Colleen Hilton said Tuesday about the ruling. “I view it as one more challenge in this very complicated workforce issue.”

The state’s Board of Arbitration and Conciliation ruled last week that firefighter Matt Lamontagne did not sexually harass firefighter Lisa Theberge during an incident in 2007 in which he touched her breast. On Tuesday, the board will hold a hearing for Lt. Donald Trafford, who is also appealing discipline by the city.

These are the second punishments both men have received from the city based on investigations into harassment claims made by Theberge and firefighter Kathy Rogers, who have been on administrative leave since the fall of 2008. But as the city deals with the fallout of claims made more than a year ago, its focus remains on creating an environment in the department so that the female firefighters can come back to work.

However, City Administrator Jerre Bryant admits that trying to re-incorporate Lamontagne into the department while simultaneously working on getting the women back on the job isn’t an ideal situation.

“It makes it more challenging,” he said.

Advertisement

But the city’s in a better position than ever to make it work. Earlier this month, two management firms were hired to take over the leadership roles in the department. In January, Hilton laid off both the fire chief and the deputy chief in favor of bringing in the temporary leadership consultants. At the same time, the Center for the Prevention of Hate Violence continues its intensified training of all members of the department in harassment prevention and communication.

Since her campaign for mayor, Hilton has made clear that righting the situation in the fire department would be a top priority for her. She said Tuesday that she’s not surprised or discouraged by the continued complications.

“We’ll get it straightened out. I’m confident of that,” Hilton said.

Bryant said he’s not sure when Lamontagne will return to work, but it would be soon. The state arbitration board awarded Lamontagne back pay for the time he’s spent unemployed since being fired in December.

According to Howard Reben, attorney for Teamsters Local 340, the firefighters’ union, the state board’s unanimous decision in favor of Lamontagne indicates that the city is wasting time and money on its attempts to discipline firefighters.

Reben said he thinks the reason for punishing the firefighters could be to build a stronger defense for Rogers and Theberge’s pending lawsuits against the city, potentially saving money on eventual settlements.

Advertisement

Rogers has already twice settled with the city, once in 1994 and again in 2004, when she received $76,000 through five years, as well as 540 hours of sick time and $39,000 for legal fees.

Hilton rejected Reben’s theory.

In its case against Lamontagne, the city claimed he sexually harassed Theberge by touching her breast while demonstrating on her body where to place electrodes used on patients who are having heart problems.

Theberge did not include the incident, which occurred in 2007, among the 150 incidents involving 20 firefighters listed in her claim against the city in 2008. The city became aware of her interaction with Lamontagne through new testimony from an eyewitness. That spurred a subsequent investigation by the city in 2009, which led to Lamontagne’s second punishment. Aside from ruling that Lamontagne was not harassing Theberge, the arbitration board pointed to the fact that the Maine Human Rights Act requires sexual harassment claims to be made within 300 days of an incident.

Though Rebecca Webber, attorney for the female firefighters, wouldn’t say why Theberge didn’t include the incident in her claim made in September 2008, she said that the ruling sends a message to women in the state that “if they don’t file a complaint with the (Maine Human Rights) Commission about everything that has ever happened to them, they will not be protected by the arbitration panel that handles union grievances.”

The details of Trafford’s punishment will not be public until the board has made a ruling. However, Reben characterized the city’s case against him as the weakest it’s made against a firefighter so far.

Advertisement

“I’d rather see these people not have to go through these ordeals,” Reben said.

Trafford was first disciplined in December 2008, when the city punished seven firefighters following an investigation into sexual harassment claims made by Theberge and Rogers.

Demoted from lieutenant to firefighter, Trafford received the harshest punishment of the seven members of the department and was the only one to file a grievance against the city. In that round of discipline, Lamontagne received a 60-day suspension. According to the report from his arbitration last month, Lamontagne agreed not to appeal the punishment in order to keep his job.

In June 2009, the state arbitration board overturned Trafford’s demotion and reinstated him as a lieutenant. As Reben’s client now pursues a second appeal, he said he wonders “when is enough.”

“I think he’s being treated unfairly by having to have this arbitration. It’s inappropriate,” Reben said.

But Bryant points to the fact that in the first case against Trafford, he wasn’t cleared of all wrongdoing. Though the board overturned the demotion, it agreed with a majority of the city’s argument about his inappropriate behavior but decided a two-week suspension was the proper punishment.

“It’s not a win-lose situation. It’s trying to clean up the workplace through a whole variety of approaches,” Bryant said.

With the heightened awareness of harassment issues and strong leadership in place, Hilton said, moving forward, any possible infringement of sexual harassment policy will be carefully documented and quickly acted upon. Regardless of the state arbitrators’ rulings, she said, she would not hesitate to discipline a firefighter for inappropriate behavior.

“We will again seek termination,” Hilton said.

Comments are no longer available on this story