8 min read

Schools all over Maine are facing a grim reality this budget season – there’s less money available in the form of state education aid.

That has led to belt-tightening and forced schools to find creative ways to raise money. One such way is through participation fees for sports and extracurricular activities, commonly known as “pay-to-play.”

Several southern Maine school districts, have begun to discuss implementing a pay-to-play system for sports and activities. In Scarborough, which dropped participation fees two years ago, the budget passed this week by the school board includes $200,000 in participation fees, and a fee system was debated in South Portland. The budget proposal for the Windham-Raymond School District includes a pay-to-play system as well. Some schools, like Cape Elizabeth High School and Gray-New Gloucester High School, have already put the fees in place.

School athletic officials and coaches said they don’t see a pay-to-play system impacting the number of students who take part in sports, largely because of waivers offered to families who can’t afford the fees. Participation fees, they said, are a way to avoid cutting programs altogether, and part of a trend that has students and their families funding a greater portion of their school’s activities budget.

JUDGING THE IMPACT

One local school that has gone down the road of pay-to-play is Cape Elizabeth. Athletic Director Jeff Thoreck said the high school charges an annual $125 “athletic participation fee” for each student taking part in sports. He said the fee, which has been in place for four years, covers the entire year and applies only to the students in the athletic programs. “Unfortunately it’s a reality of where we are economically,” Thoreck said.

Advertisement

Students at Cape Elizabeth Middle School, Thoreck added, are also subject to participation fees, but under a different structure. Since the middle school’s program is run by Cape’s Community Services department, Thoreck said, the department collects a $40 administration fee, plus a $50 per sport played and a refundable $20 uniform deposit.

Addressing the concern that some families might not be able to afford the fees, Thoreck said a system in place where families of middle and high school students can apply for assistance. He said the money comes out of the Community Services budget, and is awarded based on need. Thoreck said he knows of no families who have been denied aid when they have sought it.

“It’s a fair program,” he said. “We try to make (assistance) as available and confidential as possible. Our intention is not to stop anyone from participating.”

Thoreck said the athletic participation fees account for about $40,000 of the athletic department’s budget. That influx of money has saved the department from having to make major cuts, he said.

“We haven’t eliminated any programs,” Thoreck said.

One argument made against pay-to-play is that it can reduce the number of kids that go out for sports. Cape boys basketball coach Jim Ray, who has coached the Capers for 16 seasons, said the fees haven’t had a noticeable effect on his team. “I have noticed zero difference in how our program is run with pay-to-play,” he said. “I can’t speak for other coaches, though.”

Advertisement

The fees, he said, help preserve programs.

“Unfortunately that’s the way things are going, budget-wise,” Ray said. “Way back, maybe something like 10 years ago, they wanted the booster program to completely fund our freshman program, and I said I wasn’t going to endorse that as a coach. I think that if you (the school) value it educationally, then you should fund it.”

According to Ken Pierce, the president of the Cape Elizabeth Baseball Boosters, the booster organizations have taken on more of the burden over the past few years. Pierce, who has two sons playing sports at the high school, said the boosters currently pay the stipends of the freshman baseball coach and the assistant varsity coach, and might soon do even more.

“The boosters might be required to provide things as elementary and fundamental as baseballs,” he said, adding that the basketball boosters provided some basketballs for the team this year.

In addition, Pierce said, the baseball boosters have paid for practice equipment during the past few years and also raised the money to construct dugouts at the high school’s baseball and softball fields.

Addressing the participation fees, Pierce said that he doesn’t like them because he believes they deter some kids from playing sports, but barring a townwide tax increase, he sees the need for the fees.

Advertisement

“The reality is that parents of kids in schools have to cover more of the burden,” he said.

At Gray-New Gloucester High School, a $25 per sport activity fee has been in place for the past four to five years, according to Athletic Director Melanie Craig, who added that there is also a $100 cap per family per school year.

Craig said that while she would rather not have to collect the fees, the community seems to accept the reason for them. “There hasn’t been an outcry from the community,” she said. “I think everybody’s aware of the economic times.”

While the fee is only applicable to sports right now, Craig said that will expand next year to cover other groups that attend competitions, such as: drama, the math team and Destination Imagination, which she described as a “problem-solving creative group”.

Craig said that the school grants waivers to any student eligible for the free lunch program and students who qualify for the reduced lunch program pay half the fee. She said about five percent of students in the school’s athletic programs qualify for the waivers.

She said that in addition to the waivers, the district has been committed to make sure every student is able to play sports, despite the fee. To that end, there are scholarships available to help out families going through tough times and the booster clubs also offer assistance.

Advertisement

As a result of all the assistance available, Craig said Gray-New Gloucester has been able to avoid any drop in participation in the school’s athletic programs. “Our participation has actually gone up,” she said.

LOOKING AHEAD

In Windham, the topic of participation fees has come up in previous years, but Merrill said the idea had never been implemented at the high school.

Merrill said he has been resistant of putting in participation fees because of a concern that the extra cost would drive some students from the athletic program. “The concern is that there are going to be kids or families that cannot afford it, and as a result, not participate,” he said.

But, despite that concern, economic realities may be forcing a change at Windham starting next year.

On Wednesday, Merrill presented a proposed athletic budget to the school committee that included a $50 participation fee for high school athletics with an annual family cap that is still to be determined. “It’s not a recommendation that I want to make or like to make,” he said. “(But) clearly we just have to try and do things differently.”

Advertisement

Merrill said with the number of students participating in athletics in Windham increasing every year, he views the participation fee as a way to avoid having to make any drastic cuts in the athletic budget. “Rather than cutting, we’re trying to increase the revenue stream,” he said, adding that he recognizes that families already spend hundreds of dollars each season on equipment and other items. “Certainly the last thing we want to do is make it more difficult for people.”

While the Windham school board would still have to approve the fees, Merrill said work is ongoing on developing a waiver system for families that cannot afford them.

For the past two years, Scarborough High School has not charged students a fee to participate in sports, but could change. The 2010-11 school budget reinstates a fee for sports and other activities, with the exception of the service-based groups.

The school did away with the fees two years ago, Athletic Director Gary Groves said, as part of the school’s participation in the University of Maine’s “Sports Done Right” program, which seeks to make school sports available to all students with no limits like participation fees.

Once the previous fee was eliminated, Groves said, there was no discernible increase in the number of students taking part in sports. He said the school has averaged about 350-400 athletes per sports season and that’s been a consistent number over recent years. “We’ve held pretty steady,” he said.

Groves said while he doesn’t personally support a fee structure, he knows that the current economic climate has made such measures necessary.

Advertisement

“We’re in some real tough times,” he said. “We’re in a climate where teachers are losing their jobs and programs are getting cut.”

According to Groves, the amount of the fee hasn’t been determined, but he expects that it will be higher than the $25 fee per student per sport fee the school charged in 2008, the last year it collected the money. Groves is looking to keep the fee as low as possible while still allowing the school to collect enough money to make up for budget shortfalls. He said the amount will be determined with families in mind and there will be a waiver system in place for families having financial difficulty.

“There’s a fine line between what people can afford and what they can’t,” he said, adding that if the fee is set too high, he knows kids could be deterred from coming out for sports. “You worry about that family that won’t tell you they can’t afford it.”

While South Portland doesn’t currently charge a participation fee, Mike Giordano, the girls basketball coach at the school, said it has been discussed.

“They have been talking about it,” he said. “But as it stands right now we don’t have anything like that implemented.”

Even if a fee were to be implemented, Giordano said, with the way school budgets are being tightened, he will have to make some changes.

“We’re going to be affected either way with the budgets the way they are,” he said. “Our athletic director has communicated to me that we’d be limiting our scrimmages and cutting those types of nonessential events back. We may be doing those sorts of things anyways with everyone tightening their belts as it is.”

South Portland’s Keegan Hyland drives to the hoop in a playoff game against Deering last month. South Portland school officials are creating a task force to look at implementing a pay-to-play system, an idea that is becoming more popular around the state as schools deal with tightening budgets. (File photo)

Comments are no longer available on this story