6 min read

WESTBROOK – Westbrook is forging ahead with the overhaul of its long-troubled fire department, but the price the city is paying for letting internal issues linger may make balancing the books this year very difficult.

On Monday alone, the City CounciI supported spending money – likely as much as $100,000 – on insurance deductibles for two sexual harassment claims, attorneys’ fees for a special legal project and contracts with two outside management companies – all costly items city officials say are necessary for turning around the fire department.

The council will vote to give final approval on those expenditures at its next meeting, either a special meeting on March 22 or the regularly scheduled meeting on April 5.

But, with a $20.4 million budget that has already seen cutbacks, where that money will come from – and just how much will need to be spent – is not yet clear.

“It absolutely concerns me,” said Council President Brendan Rielly. “I don’t think any of us want to be spending money right now. I don’t think we have much choice.”

Councilor Michael Foley, the chairman of the Finance Committee, said the areas in which the city has overspent would have to be covered by funds not used in other accounts. For example, he said, because the winter has been mild so far, the Public Services Department hasn’t used up its money budgeted for salt and sand for the roads.

Advertisement

City Administrator Jerre Bryant said areas like storm expenses are exactly where he’s looking for money to cover the costs of over-expended accounts, but it’s a tough balance.

“The fact that it rained this weekend and didn’t snow was real, real good news to me,” Bryant said about the savings in snow removal and sanding the warmer weather afforded.

In anticipation of losing state revenues and incurring additional expenses this year, the city laid off three employees in January and directed department heads to curtail spending by $190,000 before the end of fiscal year in June.

Bryant said the city also has contingency account of $100,000 that will help cover costs.

But regardless of where the money comes from, Foley said, state law prohibits the city from operating in deficit and officials will have to figure it out.

“We’re going to have to balance the budget,” he said.

Advertisement

Rielly said he thinks the city could have saved taxpayers’ money by moving “sooner and more aggressively” to address issues in the fire department.

“But right now we have a mess and we need fix it,” he said.

Since female firefighters Kathy Rogers and Lisa Theberge made sexual harassment claims and went on paid leave in September 2008, the city has been scrambling to undo the damages, including poor leadership and a disrespectful culture in the fire department.

Former Fire Chief Gary Littlefield abruptly retired right after Rogers and Theberge went on leave and just before seven members of the department were disciplined for their inappropriate behavior or failure to take action against it.

The city hired a new chief, Daniel Brock, and brought in the Center for the Prevention of Hate Violence to assess the department’s problems and train its members on the proper ways to behave in the workplace, communicate with co-workers and respond to inappropriate conduct.

But that wasn’t enough for new Mayor Colleen Hilton. In her inaugural address in January, she announced that she was not reappointing Brock and would instead hire an outside management firm to run the department for a 12-month transition period. Later that week, Hilton also laid off Deputy Fire Chief Thaddeus Soltys.

Advertisement

Councilors on Monday gave preliminary approval for contracts to hire two consulting companies – Central Intelligence of Kennebunk and Municipal Resources Inc., of Meredith, N.H. – to take over administrative duties and set the fire department in a positive direction.

The city will pay Central Intelligence $70 per hour to fulfill the duties of the fire chief. Municipal Resources Inc., will perform other managerial, supervisory and administrative services at a rate of $450 per day.

In its proposal to the city, Central Intelligence said it would provide 40 hours per week of work. Municipal Resources proposed providing administrative services for two to three days per week. Hilton said the consultants’ work could take from six to 12 months.

Bryant estimated the cost for the companies through the end of June would be $50,000 to $55,000.

Bryant said the cost of the companies would be offset by the wages and benefits budgeted for Brock and Soltys.

Brock was paid at a rate of $36.61 per hour, and Soltys was paid $31.69 per hour.

Advertisement

“For the balance of the fiscal year, it’s going to be very close to a wash,” Bryant said.

In addition to the management companies, the council also gave preliminary approval to hire Portland law firm Bernstein, Shur, Sawyer and Nelson for what Bryant called “a legal research project … in the area of labor law and municipal law.”

Bryant declined to give details of the project but said the city decided to hire a firm outside of its contracted legal counsel from Jensen, Baird, Gardner and Henry because of the lawyers’ “specific expertise and experience.”

The attorneys who would be hired are Linda McGill, at a rate of $275 per hour, and Chris Vaniotis for $265 per hour.

Bryant said he didn’t know how many hours they would put in, but that the project would probably take a few weeks to complete.

“It’s a fairly intense project that needed to get done quickly,” he said.

Advertisement

Hilton would not give specifics of the project, either. However, she said, the complexities of the fire department require that it’s undertaken.

“We want to make sure we cross all our t’s and dot our i’s,” she said.

The city budgeted $160,000 for legal services this year and had spent $85,157 or 55 percent by end of January.

Meanwhile, attorneys hired by Maine Municipal Association, which administers the city’s insurance, have been performing work in response to the sexual harassment claims made and lawsuits filed against the city by Rogers and Theberge.

The city’s insurance covers those legal services, once they exceed $10,000. Bryant said he wasn’t sure how much had been spent already, but Maine Municipal Association billed the city for both claims’ deductibles, totaling $20,000 – the amount budgeted for the entire year.

According to Bryant, including those payments, the city has spent $51,000 on deductibles this year. Last year, the city also budgeted $20,000 and spent $41,500.

Advertisement

Rielly said each of the expenditures is a concern for him, but he’s most worried about how much the city is spending on overtime for firefighters.

“That’s where we’re just getting killed,” he said.

According to Rielly, the fire department’s overtime budget has been an issue for years. But since Rogers and Theberge were put on leave, forcing other firefighters to cover their shifts, the amount of money spent on overtime in that department has become “unsustainable” for the city.

“The lid’s blow off it over the past year and a half,” he said. “It’s taken a bad situation and made it intolerable.”

Bryant said the fire department had budgeted $170,000 for overtime this

year. As of Wednesday, it had spent $270,000.

Advertisement

Though there’s a lot of money being spent up front, Bryant said, the expenses are necessary for undoing past damage and moving the department forward effectively and efficiently.

The city has already settled twice with Rogers, once in 1994 and again in 2004, after the Human Rights Commission made decisions in her favor regarding sexual harassment claims. The settlement in 2004 resulted in the city paying Rogers $76,000 through five years, as well as 540 hours of sick time and $39,000 for legal fees.

Rogers and Theberge have yet to serve the city with the lawsuit they filed in October. One of the main goals of the work being done by the Center for the Prevention of Hate Violence is to have them return to their jobs.

“If we’re going to effect change in that department, we need to take corrective action,” Bryant said. “We can’t afford not to.”

Westbrook Mayor Colleen Hilton introduced Michael Pardue as the city’s new interim fire chief during a press conference Wednesday. “We’re confident in who we selected,” Hilton said. (Staff photo by Leslie Bridgers)

Comments are no longer available on this story