SOUTH PORTLAND – Despite warnings from city and school officials that drastic cuts in services and layoffs would result, several South Portland city councilors said on Monday that they don’t want to see any increase in the new municipal and school budgets.
Councilor Tom Blake said that city taxpayers cannot afford a tax hike in the economic recession. “When people at home are dipping into their resources, how can we ask them to dig even deeper?” Blake asked.
However, city and school officials said the loss of state aid and other revenues in the recession, along with increasing costs, means the 2010-2011 city and school budgets will already be in the hole before the new fiscal year begins. With no increase in funding, the only choice is to cut programs and people to come up with balanced budgets, they said.
School Superintendent Suzanne Godin said the schools’ operating budget “is so lean there’s not a place we can cut it.” She said the only areas where cuts can be made are “positions and programs.”
City Manager James Gailey said people talk about a “bare bones” budget but the municipal budget is in worse shape than that. “We’re chipping bone,” he said.
The city will have no choice but to cut services, he said. “It’s going to be significant cuts,” he predicted.
Reducing trash collection and closing the city swimming pool were mentioned as options, but Gailey stressed those were only examples and that closing the pool is unlikely.
The discussion came during a City Council and the Board of Education workshop on Monday. The annual meeting comes as the school board and the council are about to begin drawing up new budgets for the fiscal year beginning July 1.
The meeting is designed so the council can give the school board direction on how much of an increase the council would be likely to approve in the school budget. The council sets the bottom line of the school budget.
The council on Monday also gave direction to the city manager, who drafts a budget proposal to bring to the council for approval.
Blake joined councilors Rosemarie De Angelis and James Hughes on Monday in directing the city and schools to come up with new budgets that will not result in a tax increase. Blake said the city and school departments should dip into their surplus accounts to make up for budget shortfalls.
But other councilors disagreed. Councilor Patti Smith said she would support a .05 percent tax increase and Councilor Maxine Beecher favored a 1.5 percent tax increase. Councilor Linda Boudreau, who had to leave the meeting before the end, said budget variables were still in flux so she is not ready to give a number.
Mayor Tom Coward said he would support a 2.75 percent increase, an annual cap on municipal budget growth that voters statewide approved in 2004.
Coward said that not funding the budget would mean even larger tax increases in the future. “It’s false economy to trim your budget below where it’s sustainable,” he said.
And he, Gailey, Godin and Beecher said that using surplus to balance the budget is bad fiscal management. If surplus money is used to plug a hole in the budget, that hole is even greater in following years, when there likely will be no surplus to fill it, they said.
The school department currently has a surplus of about $3.5 million and the city has a surplus of about $9.5 million. The current school budget is $39 million and the current municipal budget is $29.4 million, including about $2 million in county taxes.
Both the school and the city budgets are facing a dramatic decrease in revenues in the new 2010-2011 budgets and rising expenses
Gailey said the city has a $1.3 million budget hole to plug because of a reduction of about $700,000 in the areas of state revenue sharing, motor vehicle excise tax and investment income. With such increasing costs as nearly $270,000 more in employee health insurance expenses and about $100,000 in higher fuel expenses, the city is facing a shortfall of $1.3 million going into the new budget season, he said.
The city also needs funding for paving its roads, many of which are in poor repair because the city hasn’t had the money to fix them, Gailey said. “We’re falling farther and farther behind on the roads,” he said.
On the school side, Godin said the shortfall is expected to range from $2.1 million to $2.3 million. That includes a cut in state aid of from $1.2 million to $1.4 million and increases in employee benefit costs and debt service.
Although councilors were at odds on whether they would approve any increases in the new municipal and school budgets, school board Chairman Richard Carter said after the meeting that it appears that the majority of councilors are “going to come in at (a) zero (percent increase).” He said the school board would do its best to come up with a budget at that level.
The council said it would meet with the city manager and school officials again in mid-February to review the financial outlook for both budgets.
Comments are no longer available on this story