GRAY – After two nights of testimony and a strong demonstration of support from the community, the Gray Town Council voted Dec. 10 to rescind the Nov. 16 termination of Recreation Director Dean Bennett in what some councilors described as an agonizing decision.
Bennett’s first day back to work was Thursday, a month after being fired by Town Manager Deborah Cabana for his apparent failure to correctly keep financial records. However, while Bennett was reinstated, he will lose one month of pay and benefits and has been placed on probation for the next nine months, until Sept. 15, 2010, according to the ruling made by the Town Council, who acted as judge and jury during the appeal.
The Council decided to grant Bennett’s appeal based on his lengthy service to the town, popularity of his recreation programming and his promise during the appeals process to address items that led to his original firing by Cabana.
According to a statement released Wednesday afternoon, the council, which has taken heat this week for potentially violating Maine’s Right to Know law by taking a vote on the rehiring behind closed doors, met Thursday, Dec. 17 at 5:30 to recast their votes in public.
“The vote will make the public aware of how the council voted,” said Council Chairman Peter Gellerson. “There was enough comment from the media and perhaps some citizens who felt it should be made public that Town manager Deb Cabana checked with the attorney general’s office and they said, yes, it should be made public.”
According to the council statement regarding the decision to rehire Bennett, he failed to keep proper financial records as the town’s recreation director, a shortcoming the Cabana had addressed with Bennett prior to the termination.
“We find that the Town Manager had ‘just cause’ to impose discipline on you … In particular, we find that you failed to adequately collect and account for department revenues. You have failed to correct these shortcomings in response to specific direction from the Town Manager,” the statement read.
The council, however, ruled Cabana’s termination as too harsh a penalty for Bennett’s failure to keep good records.
“We find that you are a 17-year employee and that your performance evaluations through the years have been positive. We find that you have developed innovative programming and have substantial support from the community for those efforts. We find that you have sincerely promised to correct the shortcomings identified by your supervisor, the Town Manager, and have pledged to cooperate with her and be responsive to her direction of your work in the future. We find that a sanction short of employment termination is appropriate in these circumstances,” the statement read.
After the appeal was over, Gellerson said the decision whether to reinstate Bennett was “one of the toughest things I’ve ever done. To try to make the right decision was very, very difficult.”
Under Maine’s Freedom of Access law, personnel issues are one of the few areas that can be discussed by a legislative body behind closed doors. Votes, however, are typically made in public.
Fellow councilor Matthew Sturgis, when contacted for comment earlier this week, agreed with Gellerson that the decision was a tough one. Sturgis said he’s “satisfied with the result, that the sessions were productive and I’m optimistic that we can move forward,” he said.
Sturgis also added, “the public displays of support and the e-mails we received definitely showed the impact of the town manager’s decisions” regarding Bennett. Sturgis said he tried to dwell on the facts of the case during the appeals process, rather than the emotion swirling around it, when coming to his decision.
And now that it is over, Sturgis said much has been learned as a result of the month-long saga.
“There’s a lot that people – the manager, the council and the appellant – can learn from this, and move on. It was a painful, but valuable, learning experience for all the parties involved,” he said.
Comments are no longer available on this story