South Portland may go into the energy business to help two of the city’s largest employers afford to stay in the city.
The City Council on Monday listened to a proposal that the city partner with National Semiconductor and Fairchild Semiconductor in a plan to build a city-owned energy supply company.
That new South Portland Energy company would build a natural gas-powered combined heating, cooling and power generation plant between the two businesses. It would supply electricity to Fairchild and thermal energy to both Fairchild and National.
Maine has some of the highest electricity costs in the country and those two companies, which together employ more than 2,000 well-paid workers in the city, are looking for ways to reduce their energy expenses.
According to information presented to the council, the new plant would save the companies money because it would be a highly efficient tri-generation plant. The plants are also referred to as tri-gen plants and CCHP plants – CCHP stands for combined cooling, heating and power generation. Such plants generate electricity and thermal energy and are very efficient because they reuse their own waste heat instead of emitting it as traditional power plants do.
Getting electricity from the local power plant could save Fairchild more than $1.6 million in electricity costs each year. And the city could generate revenues for itself by selling excess thermal energy the plant produces. Excess electricity the plant generates also could help lower city residents’ electricity bills, according to the proposal.
City councilors on Monday gave a qualified endorsement to further study of the proposal.
They praised the idea of South Portland producing its own energy as innovative and forward thinking, but said many outstanding questions about the plan need to be answered. Some also questioned whether South Portland should be in the energy business at all.
“Is this mission creep?” asked Councilor Linda Boudreau. She said the city’s job is to provide for the health, safety and welfare of its citizens. But this plan, she said, “sounds like we’re setting up a business model to help a business.”
Mayor Tom Blake asked whether the city has the expertise to run a power plant.
“We have a hard time controlling dogs on the beach,” he said.
Still, Blake said of the plan, “All in all, I like it.”
He and other councilors encouraged Erik Carson, assistant city manager and also the city’s economic development director, to continue to work on the proposal.
Carson presented the plan to the council at its workshop meeting.
Representatives from Fairchild Semiconductor and National Semiconductor also answered councilors’ questions, as did Paul Aubrey, president of Technical Support Inc. and of Self-Gen. Those Scarborough companies do work in the tri-generation field.
Aubrey said after the meeting that he has been volunteering his services on the project because he wants to keep the jobs at Fairchild and National in the community.
However, he said that his companies would like to be involved in the construction of the new plant. “That’s our long-term goal,” he said in an interview on Tuesday.
Carson, referring to Fairchild and National, told the council that “the purpose of this (project) is to ensure that these two companies’ energy costs don’t drive them away.”
He described the companies as critical to the city’s economic future. Both are international leaders in information technology development. Fairchild has its corporate headquarters in South Portland, and National recently consolidated 400 positions from a plant in Texas to its South Portland plant, according to Carson.
But New England, including Maine, has some of the highest electricity costs in the country, putting an expensive burden on the companies, Carson said.
According to Carson’s figures, in April 2009, the cost per kilowatt hour in New England was $16.20, when nationally the average was $9.99. Maine’s price was $12.09 per kilowatt hour, high compared to states such as Texas and South Carolina, where costs were $9.82 and $8.39, respectively.
Fairchild and National considered building the power plant themselves, but the compaies prefer to partner with the city, Carson said.
Companies prefer to work with municipalities on power plant projects because it helps the bottom line, Aubrey said. Cities and towns through the public bonding process can obtain long-term, low-interest loans.
The plant proposed would be 10,000 to 15,000 square feet and could generate an estimated 44.7 megawatt hours of electricity per year and 24,000 pounds per hour of steam power, Carson said. The plan is to primarily fuel it by natural gas.
Aubrey said the electricity this plant would generate would be enough to power about 800 homes.
He said there are thousands of tri-gen plants around the world. “Europe has been doing this for 30 years,” he said.
Some already exist in Maine, he said. For example, Eastern Maine Medical Center in Bangor has one to meet its energy needs, as does the Old Town-Orono YMCA in Old Town, he said.
Also, according to Aubrey, several municipalities – Biddeford, Rockland and Millinocket – are exploring the possibilities of tri-gen facilities.
He said the plants can be very small – about the size of a household freezer – depending on the amount of energy needed.
Carson suggested that South Portland might build more of the plants in the future to heat its own city buildings or in partnership with other businesses who want to reduce their energy costs.
Councilor Maxine Beecher said, “You’re talking clean. I like that…no odors that are going to drive me out of my home.”
However, Councilor Patty Smith questioned why the plant between National Semiconductor and Fairchild wouldn’t be fueled by a renewable source of energy, such as solar power.
Aubrey said afterward that even using a fuel such as natural gas, the plants are considered environmentally friendly because their CO2 emissions are 25 percent less than traditional power plants. And while traditional plants are about 33 percent efficient in producing energy, the tri-gen plants are 65 percent to 85 percent efficient, Aubrey said.
Carson said the next step is a pre-engineering study of the proposal to build the plant at the Fairchild and National site. He said the study would be funded in part by $50,000 from a $114,000 grant the city expects to receive from the U.S. Department of Energy. The two companies also would each contribute about $10,000 for the study.
Eventually, if the power plant plan wins council approval, a bond would have to go out to voters to pay for it. Carson said he has no estimate at this point what the cost to taxpayers might be. He said that if the plan goes forward, he hopes the plant could be online in about a year.
Comments are no longer available on this story