Members of the Pine Point Association are hoping the town will reconsider its recent decision to swap land with the owners of the Lighthouse Inn in Scarborough.
“That’s kind of our effort between now and Aug. 11,” said Pine Point member John Thurlow. “We really believe that where the vote was so close … it really deserves at least one more consideration.”
On July 15, the Town Council voted 4-3 in favor of the controversial swap.
The swap gives inn owners Nick and Peter Truman the paved portion of Depot Street in front of their 22-unit condo building/inn, consolidating the inn’s parking in front of the building. The town gets the Trumans’ current parking strip, which is approximately 22.5 feet long, to possibly create a public drop-off area, eliminating parking for cars on the sides of the road.
Under Town Council rules, any councilor who votes in favor of an issue can bring the issue up for reconsideration.
Councilors Mike Wood, Shawn Babine, Ron Ahlquist and Richard Sullivan voted for the swap. Before the vote, however, Roy and Sullivan had expressed their concerns about the swap and mentioned that more time to make a decision was needed after the July 15 public hearing.
“I’m hoping that Richard Sullivan could decide to change his mind,” Thurlow said. “It might all boil down to him for us to get this back on the agenda and reconsidered.”
Sullivan could not be reached for comment.
In the meantime, however, Town Manager Tom Hall has called representatives of the association. He is trying to create a committee to determine the best way to redevelop the area after the swap.
“In the interest of time and efficiency, I would like to assemble a small working group to assist staff in the design details for the improvement of the town-owned land,” Hall said. “For our own purposes related to the land exchange, staff has identified at least two options that can be considered. Beyond the basic conceptual design, there are important decisions regarding construction materials, aesthetics and amenities that must be considered.”
Preliminary cost estimates for any project regarding the section of Pine Point Road from East Grand to King Street is about $170,000, Hall said.
The town has received a Community Development Block Grant of $85,000, with the other $85,000 secured in the budget.
“We believe that the project is likely to come in around $140,000,” Hall said.
The town would want to have a conceptual design completed by mid-September, Hall said.
Thurlow said the association would let the town know of its decision to participate in a project committee by the end of this week.
Judy Shirk, who is also a member of the association, said she wasn’t sure if she would encourage the association to participate in the committee.
“There is still a lot of talk amongst our group,” Shirk said. “We don’t know what our next steps are. I’m not in favor of being involved in this committee, because to me it’s saying I am accepting that they gave away the road.”
The July 15 public hearing lasted more than three hours with 29 Pine Point residents speaking against the land swap. Most who spoke said the deal was not fair for the town and they didn’t want to lose Depot Street, which was built in the late 19th century. They also worried that public access to the beach at that point would be lost and the Trumans could redevelop Depot Street, blocking the view of the beach.
Currently, beachgoers walk down Depot Street to the beach. The street is sandwiched between the Trumans’ parking, a situation called a “public hazard” by Truman attorney Gene Libby of Libby, O’Brien, Kingsley and Champion.
The Scarborough Town Council this week voted against reconsidering a land swap deal with the owners of the Lighthouse Inn at Pine Point. (Rich Obrey photo)
Comments are no longer available on this story