3 min read

Cape Elizabeth town councilors Monday night voted to allow a resident to turn her residential property into a business, despite objections from neighbors.

The Council voted 4-2 to allow Lee Wilson to turn her 553 Shore Road 2.5-story Victorian home into a boutique with a second floor office and a possible third-floor apartment.

Residents who live in that area of town had urged the town in previous public hearings not to approve the change and did so again Monday night during public comments. Several residents echoed previous comments saying that Wilson had bought the property as residential in 2005 and that changing it to a business zone would damage the area’s neighborhood-friendly feel.

“We feel that 553 Shore Road is deeply embedded in a residential neighborhood,” Charles Road resident Dave Sanford said. “From the beginning we have felt this is an inappropriate property to be zoned business.”

Residents also expressed fears that another person could buy Wilson’s property and turn it into a business such as a restaurant or a garage, and that more properties in the neighborhood could be rezoned for business uses, changing the neighborhood to a business district.

Council Chairman James Rowe and Councilor David Backer voted against the change, both saying they did not see a significant reason to change the zoning.

Advertisement

“553 Shore Road was purchased by the current owner as a residence,” Backer said. “The surrounding residential neighborhood had a reasonable expectation that the properties would remain residential and that their neighbors would remain residents.”

The vote in favor of 553’s zoning change also included revisions restricting the types of businesses that can be in the building. Some of the businesses that would be allowed include barbershops, salons, shoemakers, florists and boutiques. A restaurant, however, would not be an allowable use.

Councilor Sara Lennon, who voted in favor of the zoning change, said the Council’s goal was not to create a “creeping” business district in that area.

“This does not represent growing businesses … That doesn’t make sense,” Lennon said. “I truly believe that this is going to be beneficial to everybody involved.”

Complicating the amendment change was the questionable zoning of 551 Shore Road, which is between 553 Shore Road and the existing business district. Town maps show the property as being zoned for business, but the property’s owner, Jane Waning Nicholas, said she bought the property as residential in 1992.

Nicholas had applied to have the property returned to residential zoning.

Advertisement

Peggy L. McGehee, an attorney with Perkins and Thompson, spoke on behalf of Nicholas Monday night suggesting the zoning change to 553 constitutes spot zoning. She urged the councilors to reconsider taking their vote until they looked at the zoning map again.

Cape Elizabeth has two Business A, or BA, districts. One is along Route 77 roughly between Broad Cove and Kettle Cove roads, and the other is along Shore Road near the South Portland line.

The business district overhaul, a directive of the 2007 comprehensive plan update, was designed to create a more neighborhood-friendly business district.

In addition to the 553 Shore Road amendment, the Council voted 4-2 to redefine restaurants as establishments that derive less than 25 percent of its annual revenue from the sale of alcohol and allow businesses in the southern end of Cape Elizabeth near Rudy’s of the Cape to stay open until 10 p.m. Currently businesses can stay open until 9 p.m. A business must go to the planning board if it wants to stay open past 9 p.m.

Both Rowe and Backer voted against those changes saying that traffic in those areas does not clear out at 10 p.m. and lingers well past that time.

The council also voted unanimously to reduce the required buffer around a critical wetland in the BA district.

Comments are no longer available on this story