South Portland’s $39.4 million school budget for 2009-10 and $5.8 million school maintenance bond are now in the hands of South Portland voters.
The South Portland City Council voted unanimously Monday night to endorse next year’s school spending plan, which will not increase the school tax rate. It also unanimously approved a bond to make critical upgrades to South Portland High School and the city’s two middle schools: Mahoney and Memorial.
The council’s support sends the school funding proposals to voters for final approval at a special election June 9.
The proposed school budget – totaling $39,435,123 – requires approval from a majority of registered voters before it can be formally adopted.
If the budget fails to pass, school leaders will be required to modify the budget and present it again to voters for approval.
“I’m very impressed with what the School Board has done,” said Councilor Jim Soule at the start of council deliberations Monday night.
“The state again has balanced the budget on the backs of municipalities,” said Soule, noting local schools’ loss of $875,000 in state funding.
“I extend my personal thanks to all school committee members for the work they have done with dwindling resources to deliver a zero-percent increase on the budget,” said Councilor Tom Coward. “This is what we need.”
The last time South Portland had no increase in taxes for the School Department was in the 2005-06 budget.
“It’s imperative for voters to come out next week and support this budget,” Councilor Linda Boudreau said. “It’s so incredibly important for (that to happen).”
The only criticism of the evening came from resident Albert DiMillo of Colchester Drive, who opposed as excessive the school budget and school maintenance bond.
Without directly addressing the school construction bond, DiMillo complained about duplication of services at the two middle schools and called for a consolidation of some services, if not the buildings themselves.
He criticized the city for operating five elementary schools, saying there are too many for a city of 23,000 residents.
He said there is a duplication of services at the two middle schools that could be shared, such as nurses and guidance counselors.
He complained about individual guidance counselors assigned to each elementary school, questioning how they fill their time.
DiMillo suggested that guidance counselors could travel between the two middle schools to save money.
Resident Susan Adams of Higgins Lane said: “We would lose children if we took away some of these essential services. It’s important voters understand this is an important piece of funding for South Portland schools.”
School Board member Michael Eastman stood up to counter DiMillo’s statements. “I can assure you the guidance counselors stay busy 100 percent of the time. Children coming to school today have problems we previously had never thought existed … We’re fortunate to have counselors in every elementary school.”
He noted that some elementary school students witness the effects of alcoholism at home, encounter violence, have brothers and sisters incarcerated, or live with relatives with serious mental illness. “There is nothing in the budget that is frivolous. It is all necessary,” he said.
School Board member Rick Carter noted that a third of South Portland’s student population meets poverty guidelines for free or reduced lunch. He said they come to school with multiple social needs.
DiMillo is “offering a simplistic solution” for the challenging and complicated social needs of students, he said.
School Board member Karen Callaghan seemed to direct her comments to DiMillo’s frequent complaints about the School Board’s work that he voices weekly at City Council and School Board meetings.
“I am really tired of being called a liar at every meeting and workshop,” Callaghan said. “We explain ourselves very clearly … We (the School Board) are not doing this for money but for the good of the community and children.”
One by one, the seven council members voiced support for the work of the School Board and the spending proposals.
Councilor Patti Smith remarked on the vital work of school nurses who deal with increasing numbers of children with diabetes and health problems related to obesity.
Councilor Tom Coward noted that South Portland voters have chosen over the years to have several neighborhood elementary schools instead of consolidating them. Likewise, voters decided several years ago to have two middle schools.
“There is a cost for it. I don’t think it was a mistake,” Coward said. “It just is what the voters wanted. We are not Scarborough. We are not Cape Elizabeth. We have different needs.”
Soule noted that South Portland had grappled with how many neighborhood elementary schools to keep open and settled on five, which were rebuilt with a bond approved by voters.
Likewise, residents were surveyed and chose two middle schools, instead of one.
“It may be time for a new survey, but until the people have spoken there obviously will be additional costs,” he said.
Comments are no longer available on this story