Organizers pushing for a partial ban of dogs from Willard Beach announced they have enough voter signatures to bring the issue to a citywide vote.
South Portland City Council candidate Gary Crosby said he submitted to the City Clerk’s Office petitions with 1,020 voter signatures for the proposal to appear on the November ballot.
The City Clerk’s Office, which must check and certify every signature, had not completed its review by the newspaper’s press time Tuesday, but expected to finish this week. Crosby was required to collect 930 signatures of registered voters for the ballot initiative.
At issue is a proposal by Save Willard Beach – a grassroots group headed by Crosby – to ban dogs from the popular beach for six months each year, from April 15-Oct. 15.
The ordinance would allow pets on the beach from Oct. 16-April 14 but require them to be leashed.
If Save Willard Beach has enough valid signatures from registered voters in South Portland, the proposed “six months on, six months off” rule will go before the City Council.
The council will have the option of adopting the measure or forwarding it to voters. It is expected to send it to voters, since it just revised local laws for dog walkers.
Current city law allows dogs on the beach year-round.
Under current rules, dog walkers can bring pets to the beach from 7-9 a.m. and from 7-9 p.m., from May 1-Sept.30.
Dogs are allowed on the beach all day from Oct. 1-April 30. Pets do not need to be leashed but they do need to be under voice control, according to city ordinance.
The proposed “six months on, six months off” rule is the latest salvo in an ongoing battle between the activist South Portland Dog Owners Group (DOG) and Save Willard Beach, led by Crosby and supported by several waterfront property owners.
“If the referendum passes and dogs are banned from Willard Beach for six months a year, people are still going to need to go somewhere to walk their dogs,” said Crystal Goodrich, president of DOG. “That may cause other parts of the city to become crowded, and there could be conflict in other areas as well.”
The Willard Beach neighborhood in recent years has become one of the most expensive residential areas in South Portland, with beachfront homes fetching more than $1 million. New homes built near the waterfront have prompted new complaints about pet access to the beach.
Crosby is a businessman who lives on Broadway, several miles from the beach. But he frequently speaks out on contentious issues that come before the city.
Crosby previously took a high-profile stand against a $56 million proposal to renovate South Portland High School that was defeated by voters in 2008.
He said the proposed ballot initiative to limit dogs at the beach is unrelated to his run for the District 3 council seat, currently held by Jim Soule.
Crosby, a dog owner, said he hopes a citywide vote will allow residents to put a divisive issue behind them, after years of disagreement over pet access to the heavily used beach.
“The great part about this (proposed ordinance) is that the people of South Portland will be deciding,” Crosby said. “A referendum will give us the answer and I hope people will just allow the process to take its normal flow to the people.”
Crosby lambasted DOG for discouraging residents in recent weeks from signing the petitions to bring the issue to ballot.
He called the group’s public statements against the ballot initiative “undemocratic” and accused its leaders of using “intimidation tactics.”
Crosby said that while collecting signatures he encountered residents who refused to sign because they worried about angering a friend or neighbor who supports year-round dog-walking privileges at the public beach.
“I’m being pounded on by the opposition when I’m out talking to people,” Crosby said.
“There are people who would have been happy to sign but didn’t because they live next to somebody from the Dog Owners Group, and they don’t want to get picked on. They don’t want to be subjected to it,” he said.
Goodrich denied that DOG members tried to scare people from putting their names on the petition. “We certainly did not intimidate anyone from signing anything,” she said. “The accusation that we used intimidation tactics is very serious and dramatic.”
Goodrich said her group has come out against the referendum because it does “not want to lose the four hours we have now in the warmer months” walking dogs at the beach. DOG also does not want to end the current practice of letting dogs run off leash.
“As for the undemocratic comment, everyone will have their time in the democratic process, and if it comes to it everyone will have their opportunity to go into the voting booth, pull the curtain and vote,” she said.
“Part of the democratic process is the possibility that there will be an opposing viewpoint. The Dog Owners Group opposes the Save Willard Beach group, and that is our right in a democracy. Save Willard Beach asked people to sign their petition, we have asked people to carefully consider the options before they sign it and not to sign it.”
Goodrich noted that her group has increased efforts this spring to promote “safety, respect and sharing the beach with everyone who chooses to use it.”
“There have been very few complaints this spring called into the police department, and they were only about people bringing their dogs to the beach outside permitted hours (which, by the way, is a $100 fine for the first offense),” she wrote in a letter to the editor to local newspapers. “This again shows there have been very few problems with access by dog owners to this public beach.”
Crosby’s effort to curtail dog walking at the beach has prompted emotional responses from many people who regularly gather at Willard Beach to let their pets get exercise and to socialize with other pet owners.
“Where do you think dog owners go when they are not allowed on the beach?” asked resident Anthony Young on the South Portlander, a local news blog.
“I’m sorry, if you do not go to the beach with your dog, you are missing a wonderful venue for meeting people and dogs … The privilege of being there with our dogs is a great privilege, but the misinformation (for want of better words) to remove that privilege is a travesty inflicted on us by a group with their own agenda. What will be banned on Willard Beach next if it does not conform to Gary Crosby and Save Willard Beach’s approval?”
Some members of DOG have accused some waterfront property owners of trying to limit access to the public beach. They question what other restrictions may be proposed in the future.
In addition to Crosby’s effort to limit pet access, Willard Beach property owners Dan LaBrie and Steve Gray also have argued vigorously before the City Council to restrict dog walkers. They complain of noise, unruly pets and dog droppings left behind.
“In all seriousness, do you really think it passes the straight face test … to tell us all it’s fine and maybe even healthy to play in dog crap?” Crosby wrote in the South Portlander. Crosby’s central argument is that dog urine and feces at the beach are a health risk to beach-goers.
The council agreed this past winter to clarify rules for where dogs can run off leash on the beach and to implement tougher fines for violators.
Mayor Tom Blake has said that he worries a referendum will create more divisiveness over the issue. He also has said that he hopes to promote and support many opportunities for people to get outside and use open space in the city.
Comments are no longer available on this story