4 min read

The Cape Elizabeth Town Council on Monday night tabled a rewrite of amendments to the business zoning ordinance after 40 residents spoke on both sides of the issue for nearly two hours.

Nearly half of the residents who spoke said changing the zoning would damage the residential feel of their neighborhoods, while other residents said a change would encourage smaller businesses to come in.

One of the rewrites includes changing 553 Shore Road from a residence to a business. That sparked most of the public’s interest on Monday night.

Cape resident Lee Wilson bought the property in 2005 as residential. The house is a two-and-a-half-story Victorian. Wilson wants to turn the bottom floor into a boutique, the second floor into an office and possibly turn the third floor into a studio apartment.

“All we saw and wanted was this great house that needed saving,” Wilson said. “All we hear in this town is that we want business. We hear it, yet we turn our backs on it. We make it near impossible to allow a business to come in here and try to make it thrive.”

Residents speaking in favor of Wilson’s plan echoed her sentiments.

Advertisement

“I love to shop in Cape and when I can, I like to use the businesses here,” said Jennifer Bornick, who lives on Old Fort Road. “I think that home that she is going to be using is perfect for a small business, a small retail shop.”

Residents who live near the property, however, said they worry a business at 553 Shore Road would increase traffic and noise, and affect the residential feel of the neighborhood.

“I think it’s important that the council understand, rightly or wrongly, that you have an entire neighborhood of people who really feel they’re not being listened to and they are getting bullied,” said Harry Hardy, who lives on Charles Road.

Joyce Freeman said she and her husband, David Freeman, moved to the neighborhood more than 30 years ago because of its neighborly feel. She said she fears allowing 553 to become a business would change that perception.

“The person bought the house as a residence and there is no reason to change it to a business,” said Freeman, who lives on Charles Road. “I would like to look at each and every one of you and ask you, if you lived on Charles Road … and where we live, and you had bought your house 30 years ago, could you sit here and graciously say ‘yes, we want to change this into a business’?”

Complicating the amendment change is the questionable zoning of 551 Shore Road, which is between 553 Shore Road and the existing business district. Town maps show the property as being zoned for business, but the property’s owner, Jane Waning Nicholas, said that she bought the property as residential in 1992.

Advertisement

Nicholas has applied to have the property returned to residential zoning.

“There is a major question as to the zoning status of 551 Shore Road,” said Stephen Popp, who lives on Woodland Road. “Recent public statements by the town manager and zoning officials leave the legal clarification and active status of 551 Shore Road unclear. This questionable mapping error, along with the longstanding efforts of the owners of 553 Shore Road to change zoning from residential to commercial status, could create even more commercial businesses than discussed at previous public meetings.”

Cape Elizabeth has two Business A, or BA, districts. One is along Route 77 roughly between Broad Cove and Kettle Cove roads, and the other is along Shore Road near the South Portland line.

The business district overhaul, a directive of the 2007 comprehensive plan update, is designed to create a more neighborhood-friendly business district.

In addition to the 553 Shore Road amendment, proposed changes would:

• Define a restaurant as an establishment that derives less than 25 percent of its annual revenue from the sale of alcohol.

Advertisement

• Restrict hours of operation and serving of alcohol for businesses located within 100 feet of a residential district.

• Include “bed and breakfast” as a permitted use.

• Reduce the required buffer around a critical wetland in the BA district from 250 feet to 100 feet, provided the business is served by public water and sewer.

Councilor David Backer recommended tabling a vote on the amendment changes until June. The council voted unanimously to table the issue.

“In the interim we should schedule this for a workshop to discuss and debate all the comments we heard tonight and make those efforts to tweak where appropriate and to accept where it is appropriate,” he said. “Then we can come back in June with modifications based on the comments we heard tonight.”

Comments are no longer available on this story