Declaring that South Portland officials violated “basic standards of decency” and the public’s “faith in leadership,” residents urged the City Council Monday to rehire five laid-off city workers, explain why their jobs were targeted and involve the public in finding other ways to reduce spending.
The comments – by about two dozen residents – followed a rally outside City Hall in the rain. Protesters held signs and umbrellas to call attention to the Feb. 24 dismissal of five longtime employees.
At a City Council meeting after the protest, residents questioned the management style of Dana Anderson, who oversees the departments where four of the laid-off employees worked, and called on city councilors to review the decision-making process that led to the layoffs.
The dismissed workers are Dave Gaudet, Public Works manager; Deb Smith, Recreation manager; Reta Nappi, librarian; Pam St. John, benefits clerk; and Monica Dubay, library clerk. The workers each had between 20 and 40 years of experience with the city.
Last week, Smith asked for an independent review of her termination and submitted a report to Gailey outlining concerns about the department and her dismissal. Gailey has said the city would bring in a consultant to review her concern, but the city has not made the report public.
Vicky Smith, one of the rally organizers who is not related to Deb Smith, was among the first protesters to speak at the City Council meeting Monday. As several other protesters stood silently behind her and held signs with the words “Truth” and “Accountability,” she made the following requests to the City Council and City Manager Jim Gailey:
• Reinstate the jobs of laid-off workers and find other ways to make budget cuts.
• Publicize how jobs were identified for elimination and other options considered.
• Create a better process for handling layoffs that is more “dignified” and “humane.”
• Involve the public, including citizen boards, in decision-making.
• Bring in an independent reviewer, such as a person from the Muskie School of Public Service at the University of Southern Maine, to examine the city’s current layoff process.
Gailey said the city will save $283,000 in next year’s budget because of the layoffs. The cuts are to offset an estimated $322,000 gap projected in next year’s budget from declines in revenues from state funding and local excise taxes.
Although the council did not respond to any of the comments from protestors Monday, Gailey announced at the end of the public hearing that he would post responses on the city’s Web site.
Each resident who spoke seemed to be mindful of the previous speaker and offer a different concern or perspective on the situation.
Mark Dennison – who identified himself as a resident and taxpayer – raised concerns about Anderson, who heads Public Works, Parks, Recreation and the Libraries.
Dennison alleged to the City Council that some workers in Anderson’s department use city vehicles to travel to and from personal appointments. He also accused Anderson of operating a private consulting business on city time.
Dennison said he has raised the same issues with councilors and with Gailey, but has not gotten a response.
He also questioned why Anderson’s relatives work for the city. Dennison referred to Anderson’s longtime secretary, who is his sister-in-law, and also to Anderson’s sister, who worked as a temporary employee for the city.
Neither the City Council nor Gailey responded to his accusations at the meeting Monday.
Anderson was not at the meeting, and he could not be reached for comment by Current deadline Tuesday.
In an e-mail Tuesday, Gailey said Anderson has not had a consulting business since 2000 or 2002, which predates Gailey’s role as city manager. He said Anderson married his secretary’s sister “probably 20 years ago.” He said his secretary was an employee before Anderson married her sister.
Human Resources Director John McGough has acknowledged in an e-mail correspondence with the newspaper that he hired Marcia Agger, Anderson’s sister, as a temporary employee from October 2008 to Feburary 2009.
She was paid $1,050, at $20 an hour, to improve efficiencies among the secretaries who work in some of Anderson’s departments.
McGough acknowledged the city did not advertise the job opening. “The position was not posted,” he said. “Dana Anderson recommended I speak to her.”
He added that “no one raised a conflict of interest issue with me” about hiring Agger to work in a department her brother headed.
“The City really doesn’t have a policy for hiring family members,” Gailey said in an e-mail Tuesday. “Throughout the organization, we have family members working within the same departments or in different departments.”
The city’s personnel policy states: “The City discourages the employment of individuals to work in a direct or indirect line of supervision with an employee who is a member of the individual’s immediate family. Immediate family shall include: spouse, parents, children, siblings, grandparents and grandchildren, whether by natural heritage or law.”
Former city attorney Mary Kahl also spoke during the public comment period. She urged the council to involve itself in reviewing Gailey’s decision to lay off the five veteran workers, instead of looking at other ways to trim the budget.
Mayor Tom Blake has said the city’s current legal counsel says it is outside the City Council’s purview to question the city manager’s decision making in personnel matters.
But Kahl argued that the council does have authority over fiscal matters and that layoffs for budgetary reasons are different from terminations or firings.
“The city manager (answers) to the council for administration of the budget. The council is responsible for all fiscal decisions. The buck stops with the City Council.”
Resident Courtney Ferrell of Spring Street said she wants to know what kind of training other workers are getting to cover the duties of the laid-off workers.
Just as senior managers have been compensated for taking on extra duties under the city’s consolidation, she said, workers should be rewarded for taking over the jobs of people who were dismissed.
She also questioned why Nappi, the teen-room librarian, was laid off just as she completed her master’s degree in a tuition program paid for by the city.
Former City Councilor Rosemarie De Angelis said she was outraged by the layoffs and how they were handled.
“The process needs to be reviewed in detail,” said De Angelis, adding that she is tired of hearing some councilors say “it is time to heal and move on.”
“I’m not interested,” she said. “The wound is deep… Back up and reconsider what you’ve done. It is not up to us to do the healing.”
Comments are no longer available on this story