2 min read

A Sebago woman’s case claiming discrimination against Anthem Health Plans of Maine and Wellpoint will go to trial after a ruling March 27 by the U.S. Court of Appeals in Boston.

Laurie Chadwick’s suit claims she was denied a promotion in favor of a less qualified applicant because she had four children, including 6-year-old triplets. She was told that the decision was not based on anything she did or didn’t do, but because she “had too much on her plate,” according to her lawyer, David Webbert.

“It was very demoralizing to be told that my promotion was denied because of my kids even though I had been very loyal to my job and earned the promotion based on my performance,” Chadwick said in a statement issued by Webbert.

While a federal court in Maine previously ruled Chadwick didn’t have a case, the recent court of appeals ruling means she will have a jury trial in Portland. She could be awarded back pay, damages of up to $300,000 and payment of attorney’s fees and expenses.

At the same time as Chadwick’s case goes forward, the state Legislature will consider a bill sponsored by Rep. Cynthia Dill (D-Cape Elizabeth) to expand protections against workplace discrimination to include family caregivers.

Chadwick began working at Wellpoint in 1997. After nine years with positive performance reviews, Chadwick applied for a supervisory position in her department in June 2006. At the time, she had 6-year-old triplets in kindergarten and an 11-year-old son.

Advertisement

Chadwick was one of two finalists for the position, with the other being another in-house candidate with less experience.

The woman who made the hiring decision told Chadwick she was concerned about Chadwick having too much on her plate with her kids, taking on a new role at work, traveling in her new position and taking a class. The supervisor said she thought Chadwick would be happier in the future because she was denied the promotion.

Dr. Mary Still, who has a Ph.D. in sociology and is a post-doctoral research fellow at Cornell University’s Institute for Social Sciences, testified that social science research confirms there is a prevailing stereotype that women with young children will not perform as well in the workplace.

“This landmark ruling sends a strong message to employers and is a major step forward in ensuring equal opportunity for women with young children,” Webbert said.

Neither Chadwick nor representatives from Anthem Health Plans of Maine and Wellpoint returned calls for comment by the Lakes Region Weekly deadline.

Comments are no longer available on this story