4 min read

South Portland officials refused Monday to disclose the contents of a report that Deb Smith prepared for City Manager James Gailey, after being laid off from her job managing the Recreation Department for 27 years.

“We have come to a decision,” Gailey said in an e-mail Monday. “The City cannot provide (the newspaper) with a copy of it because it is confidential.”

Gailey cited a Maine statute that protects the confidentiality of public employees accused of misconduct.

The Maine law named by Gailey refers to personnel files. The law states in part that records should remain private when they contain “complaints, charges and accusations of misconduct… (and) charges or accusations and any other information or materials that may result in disciplinary action.”

Gailey said he personally reviewed Smith’s “statement,” which she forwarded to the city manager after being denied an exit interview.

He also pledged Monday to bring in an outside consultant to “conduct an independent review” of her concerns.

Advertisement

Smith expressed dismay this week upon learning of the city’s refusal to make the report public. “I would like my attorney to address the issue of having it released or not,” said Smith, declining to elaborate.

Smith said that in her statement to the city manager, she asked for an independent investigation of her termination.

Smith said she is pleased Gailey chose to follow through on that request. But she declined to elaborate on what else she wrote in the report.

Smith – well-known for growing the recreation center programs – has said publicly that she believes complaints she made to city leaders resulted in her termination.

But Gailey has said the layoffs of Smith and four other veteran workers were financially driven, an effort to close a budget gap next fiscal year.

The city’s decision not to release her report to the city manager seemed to raise more questions among residents about the circumstances that led to the layoffs.

Advertisement

“There has been such a swirl of confusion and sense that someone, somewhere is not being wholly candid” about the layoffs, said resident Vicky Smith, who’s helping to organize a rally to protest the layoffs.

“I really had hoped the report would be made public” to ease concerns and answer some questions.

Smith noted that Gailey had assured the public that front-line services in the city were not affected in the layoffs. Yet, she said, the Young Adult Resource Room at the library was closed, affecting services to teens. “Someone, somewhere is not telling the truth,” she said.

Resident Don Russell said he hopes Smith will release the report. “The report needs to be made public,” said Russell, a Planning Board member. “It seems appropriate for everyone to be heard for the sake of transparency. It appears that the only way it may happen is through Deb Smith and her attorney.”

Russell added “that it is obvious an independent review needs to be administered… The public deserves that,” he said. “I’ve tried to be balanced and look at both sides. There are still a lot of unanswered questions. We need to get to the solution stage here.”

On Feb.24, Smith and four other longtime workers were ordered to leave the workplace immediately after being told they had lost their jobs due to budget cutbacks.

Advertisement

The other laid-off workers are librarian Reta Nappi, public works manager Dave Gaudet, library clerk Monica Dubay and human resources assistant Pam St. John.

The city said it chose mid-level managers for termination to protect direct services to the public. Most of the affected workers had more than 20 years working for the city.

Smith said she had complained to her boss, Dana Anderson, about operations at the Community Center prior to her termination. Anderson directs Public Works, Parks, Recreation and Libraries, reporting directly to Gailey.

Smith has declined to provide details of that conversation.

Anderson has not spoken publicly about Smith’s termination, which has sparked dozens of complaints from residents.

A protest and rally are planned for Monday, at 6:15 p.m., in front of City Hall, prior to the regularly scheduled City Council meeting at 7 p.m.

“As someone who followed this closely, I’m pleased that a third-party investigator is being called in. It’s clear there are issues that need to be addressed,” said former City Councilor David Jacobs, who initially was hired by Smith to act as her spokesman after her termination. He is no longer representing Smith.

“But I’m disappointed the city has chosen not to release the report to the public,” Jacobs added. “It is clear that people want answers and this adds to the angst the public is feeling.”

Comments are no longer available on this story