The owners of the Maine Mall will get a third chance to appeal their 2006 property tax bill, when they go before the Maine Board of Property Tax Review on April 8.
General Growth Properties is scheduled to argue its case in Augusta during a three- or four-day hearing to review a 2006 abatement request that the South Portland Tax Assessor denied.
The dispute centers on South Portland’s 2006 assessment, which valued the mall property at $266 million. The request involves $3.5 million in property taxes General Growth paid for the 2006-07 fiscal year.
The Chicago-based mall owner claims the property actually is worth $190 million, or $76 million less than the city’s valuation.
South Portland stands to lose $900,000 in annual tax revenues, if the state board supports General Growth’s assertion.
After Tax Assessor Elizabeth Sawyer rejected the mall owner’s plea in 2007 to lower its assessment, General Growth took its case to the South Portland Board of Assessment Review. The board upheld the city’s assessment, prompting the mall owner to appeal to the state board.
Next month, the state Property Tax Review Board will hold a “de novo” hearing, meaning members will hear the evidence for the first time, instead of rendering a decision by reviewing past rulings.
The governor-appointed board is composed of attorneys, retired assessors, engineers and others with a background in assessments in Maine.
Meanwhile, General Growth recently received a declaratory judgment in Cumberland County Superior Court to make its appraisal report confidential.
Attorney Jon Goldberg of Portland argued that the report discloses contractual agreements with business partners and vendors, as well as rental agreements, which it needs to keep private to stay competitive.
By granting the declaratory judgment, the court ruled that the appraisal report must be kept under seal and not disclosed as a public document during the state board hearing.
General Growth bought the mall for $270 million in 2003, but claims the higher price reflected the mall’s name brand, not the value of the property and buildings.
If General Growth loses again, it can file an appeal in Superior Court. The case could make it all the way to the Maine Supreme Court.
Its property tax dispute with South Portland is unrelated to the Chicago company’s bigger financial problems in meeting mortgage payments on some of the 200 mall properties it owns.
The nation’s second-largest mall operator has disclosed it is on the verge of bankruptcy, as it struggles to find new investors and renegotiate loans in the tight credit market.
General Growth has asked its lenders to halt any legal action against the firm from March 16 through Dec. 31, 2009, and to set new re-payment terms on all of the debt it owes.
In the company’s 2008 annual report, General Growth Properties listed $1.18 billion in past due debt and an additional $4.09 billion in debt that could be accelerated by lenders, if it cannot meet its obligations.
The company owns or manages 200 shopping malls in 44 states.
In Maine, South Portland officials plan to hire a consultant to review the Maine Mall and all commercial properties later this year to determine if an adjustment is needed, based on current market conditions.
Sawyer noted that “April 1, 2009, is a whole new ball game,” in terms of commercial property values. “What we do this year may be something very different from what we did in April 2006,” given today’s weaker real estate market and challenging economy.
The city will contract with Boston-area appraiser Steve Traub. He has many years of experience working on the city’s commercial property assessments, including the Maine Mall.
As Traub launches his review of commercial properties, Sawyer’s office will do a more generalized review of all property values in the city to determine if there needs to be “a downward adjustment” from the 2006 revaluation.
“Residential, commercial and industrial properties have suffered declines as a result of the economic hardships, and it may be prudent to look at the 2006 numbers and reduce them,” she said.
Sawyer said it is possible that there may be a downward assessment on all properties, valued at $4 billion.
But a lower citywide valuation will not result in lower property tax bills, if the city maintains its current level of spending. The local tax rate is based on spending needs and the budget the City Council adopts.
If the city’s revaluation were to decline, the tax rate would have to rise in order to collect the same amount of revenue.
Comments are no longer available on this story