3 min read

There’s something growing under the sink, and it’s multiplying – by the minute.

That ball of plastic bags just keeps getting bigger, pushing aside the assortment of household cleaners wedged next to it. Yes, yes, we know. Reusable bags. We’ve been meaning to buy them. But even our friends who have them occasionally forget to bring them to the store.

We have, after all, no incentive to use them, other than to save the environment. But who has time to think about the environment, when we’ve got a job to worry about, kids to take to hockey practice, dinner to make? Not to mention three other errands to run before we even get to the grocery store.

A Maine legislator is once again offering to give us that incentive, in the form of a 10-cent tax on disposable plastic bags. The proposal, from Sen. John Nutting, D-Leeds, is similar to one last year that would have imposed a 20-cent tax on disposable bags at grocery stores. The new proposal would apply to all stores.

Despite strong arguments in favor of it, including one that appeared on this page, that bill suffered a fate worse than the wastebasket: Lawmakers failed to pass it, opting instead to pass a joint resolution encouraging the public to reduce the use of disposable plastic shopping bags. Not surprisingly, it’s had little measurable effect on the habits of consumers, who don’t usually check their list of legislative resolutions before heading to the grocery store.

Taxes similar to this one are being discussed throughout the country because disposable plastic bags are huge part of our waste stream. Some estimates put the usage of them worldwide in the hundreds of billions. Most of them start as crude oil, natural gas or other petrochemical derivates. Some manufacturers now make biodegradable bags, but they are cost prohibitive and make up only a small fraction of the bags used.

Advertisement

While many grocery stores now promote the use of reusable bags, taxes on disposable bags have proven to be the only effective way to have a significant effect on the amount used. In Ireland, for example, a 33-cent-per-bag tax is credited for reducing the amount of disposable bags there by 90-95 percent. Critics say it’s led to an increase in plastic bag purchases, which is an argument similar to ones made against such a tax in Maine.

Opponents point out that people reuse plastic bags for all sorts of things, like lining a litter box or wastebasket. But let’s face it, lining a litter box is not recycling a plastic bag; it’s using it twice before throwing it away. People who have reusable shopping bags don’t go out and buy five or six plastic bags a week – the average number for most consumers – to replace the small, disposable bags that are no longer in their life. They’d likely require half that, or fewer if they’re recycling more.

However, the reality is most consumers will stick to their habits – unless they have an economic incentive to change. Just as pay-per-bag trash programs have been effective at increasing the amount of recycling that’s done at the curb, a 10-cent tax in the checkout line could have the same effect.

Brendan Moran, editor

Comments are no longer available on this story