The group that tried to bring a racino to Scarborough Downs last fall could face up to $61,000 in fines if the state’s ethics commission finds it knowingly was late in filing two campaign expense reports.
The Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices will rule in March whether Scarborough Village Partnership PAC violated the law.
The PAC could also face a $250 fine if the commission finds it knowingly registering late with the Scarborough town clerk. The commission was ready to vote Jan. 29 on that issue, but Dennis Bailey, spokesman for Casinos No!, which opposed the racino proposal, asked the commission to postpone the decision until his group had a chance to meet with ethics officials.
According to the ethics commission’s findings, the PAC registered on Sept. 26 and filed its first campaign finance report on Oct. 24. Commission Chairman Jonathan Wayne said the PAC should have registered on Aug. 26 and filed its campaign financing reports by Oct. 10.
A Scarborough citizens group called Save our Scarborough enlisted the help of Casinos No! last year to battle the racino proposal, Bailey said. When Casinos No! began investigating Scarborough Village Partnership’s PAC in October, it was shocked to see that the PAC had not filed yet, Bailey said.
“They were already doing ads, mailings and saying paid for by Scarborough Village Partnership, and we complained,” Bailey said. “It was just odd to us that there was no public accountability.”
Downs officials had proposed adding slots to the track as a part of a $200 million commercial and residential development that would give the town a center and $8 million in annual revenues.
Pitched by Connecticut developer Gene Beaudoin, the proposal
to develop 535 acres owned by the track lost by just 239 votes. It was backed by Penn National Gaming Inc., which spent more than $60,000 on a campaign in support of the project, according to campaign finance reports.
The late filing was not done purposely, Beaudoin said.
“I can’t speak for Penn Gaming, but I can tell you that the mistakes that were made were minor in nature and purely accidental,” Beaudoin said.
Ed MacColl, an attorney representing Scarborough Downs, did not return phone calls to The Current.
Wayne said the ethics commission will look at the issue again and will have a decision at its March 28 meeting.
The late filings could stem from a change last year in the filing deadline that Scarborough officials were not aware of, Wayne said, adding that PAC officials were told they had until Oct. 24 to file.
“There appears to be a little bit of ambiguity in the law,” he said.
According to the ethics commission’s report, Justice told the PAC’s treasurer, Kathryn Rolston, that Scarborough Village Partnership had until Sept. 26 to register as a PAC and had until Oct. 24 to file its campaign finance reports.
Wayne said the confusion was “an honest mistake” on Scarborough’s part and he doesn’t believe Scarborough officials had any malicious intent.
Scarborough Town Clerk Tody Justice declined to comment for this story.
Bailey said he understands that mistakes might have been made, but he isn’t convinced the late filing wasn’t intentional.
“They said there were mistakes made and they got bad information, and maybe they did,” Bailey said. “It was in our view as part of their strategy they were downplaying the gambling portion of this project and focusing more on the village part. I think it’s a serious violation.”
Wayne said he believes the commission will more seriously look at issuing up to a $10,000 fine for one of the late expense filings and look at imposing a $250 fine for registering late.
“I think the commission members are not bound by that and will be taking an independent look at all the facts and making a judgment as to what penalty to appropriate,” Wayne said.
Comments are no longer available on this story