To paraphrase former Sen. Joseph McCarthy (yes, that one), “Are you now, or have you ever been, enrolled in a political party and also, simultaneously, serving either Cape Elizabeth or Scarborough as a member of the Town Council, state House of Representatives, Zoning Board, Planning Board, state Senate, Lobster Preservation Committee, Committee to Irritate Clamdiggers by Allowing All Kinds of People with Massachusetts License Plates to Dig on the Same Flats My Grandfather Dug On, Committee to Pave Scarborough East of the Maine Turnpike, or other local or state boards, and done so knowingly, voluntarily and intentionally?”
If you answered yes, you may have a claim under the Geneva Convention for maltreatment or mental torture.
No, no, no. This is not a print commercial for the law offices of James Sokolove. This has to do with the Barnum and Bailey shows that have taken place both in Illinois, and more recently in New York State, concerning vacant seats in the U.S. Senate.
Did you see who got picked to replace Sen. Hillary Clinton, who has gone on to become secretary of state?
U.S. Congresswoman Kirsten Gillibrand.
OK, OK – I know what you are saying, you l5-year-olds out there in Reader Land: “Big whoop … and all this interests me, whyyyyyyyyyyy?” (taking care to stretch out all one-syllable words into at least three, or be in violation of Paragraph 3, subpart two, sentence C of The Rules of Disney Channel, which require snide, sarcastic responses to all questions or statements from adults).
Congresswoman Gillibrand is a Democrat. But her appointment by the New York governor has rankled many New York politicos because Gillibrand is – gasp! – a political conservative. In the past, her views (e.g., in favor of Second Amendment gun rights) have been “tolerated” by the Democratic leadership in Washington because “they know she represents a conservative, traditionally Republican district in upstate New York,” one journalist said the other day.
Man, do all these comments ring a bell!
I represented Scarborough in the state Legislature from l984 through l988. I was a Democrat (pause at typewriter; dodge thrown vegetables; OK, resume typing).
Scarborough is, or was, or used to be, “historically, a conservative, Republican-leaning town.”
One walks a tightrope when one is a different color, flavor or stripe politically than people were in that town, say, 200 years ago.
How did I do it?
Do you think I am stupid, dear reader? If I told you now, you would coldly and callously cease reading this column, and I am only halfway done!
If you have been in political-party politics in either Cape or Scarborough – especially the past 25 years – you know that this New York congresswoman has had to go through a lot, politically.
She has no doubt been pressured on social legislation, foreign aid questions, judicial nominations, education philosophy issues, and various spending matters.
People take their politics seriously.
If a voter is an older Republican, they may well not be that interested in your support for Rep. Meddybemp’s bill to require seat and shoulder belts for tricycles.
If a voter in your town is a 20-something Democrat, he or she may not dig your voting in favor of legislation authored by the Garden Club to mandate that dogs wear pants in public (lest they continue to parade naked around small children on the beach, and in parks!).
I have no idea, for example, what Rep. Cynthia Dill goes through in Cape Elizabeth as a Democrat. I still think of Cape Elizabeth as a “bastion of Republicanism,” which was the phrase used after each and every mention of Cape in Associated Press political stories in the l960s and ’70s. That is probably no longer true. (Come to think of it, I know when my friend and Scarborough export Phin Sprague ran for office in Cape about eight or l0 years ago, his statement at his opening press announcement that he owned, basically, much of the land in Cape that wasn’t owned by the town and/or had gone up for sale when he wasn’t looking, was not the vote-getter it would have been 30 years ago).
This lady in New York probably deserves this U.S. Senate appointment – as a “job well done” for getting at least 5l percent of the voters in her district to elect her twice, despite the fact that congresspeople don’t spend as much time on dairy farmer issues as they do on urgent measures to stop genocide in Darfur or other places many miles from the local hardware store.
(OK, so she will be eaten alive by Andrew Cuomo in the Democratic primary campaign a couple years from now, but all those Senate photos she will frame will look good on her mantel at home years from now.)
How does one survive in a district that is historically different in philosophy and representation than the methods preferred by the current officeholder?
It’s easy.
You follow the advice of former State Rep. Vern Lent, who won as a Democrat in Scarborough in l964 in the “LBJ Landslide.”
You lie a lot.
No!!! Just kidding!
What you do is called “restructural issue positioning.” Political science professor Kenny Hayes taught us that at the state university many years ago. Taxpayer money well spent.
Here is what that means – and what Vern did in Augusta.
Let’s say I vote in favor of a bill to ban dumping chemicals into Maine rivers. Let’s say the bill provides reasonable Gestapo means of enforcement of the bill’s provisions, and Republicans consider it more anti-business bias from the Maine Legislature.
I then need to find out what those Republican neighbors of mine are in FAVOR of. Local control? Supporting Maine businesses over out-of-state or foreign companies?
Dismantling certain state agencies?
I then spin my vote against poisons, and for fines against poisoning companies, as having been cast for that reason.
We don’t lie, boys and girls.
We just tell mommy we took the cookie from the cookie jar to help stop world hunger – ours!
To wit: “Our legislative investigation showed that 90 percent of the pipes used by companies polluting Maine rivers were actually manufactured either in Wisconsin, or China. We cannot allow this. Until these companies – all owned by shareholders incorporated in Delaware, by the way – start using pipe manufactured by Maine businesses, I will not allow this foreign-aiding use of pipe to continue.”
And on other bills on other issues, same approach.
A bill to criminalize a driver who keeps his right blinker on for more than five of the seven miles of Route One, heading from the South Portland line, to the Saco line?
“We have found the blinker units are all made up of parts made by underage children working in sweat-shop assembly lines in Bangkok. We will not stand for further use of these blinkers in
Maine. As with the river-polluting bill that cracked down on pipes manufactured outside Maine, we will send elderly people to jail here as a message to manufacturers that the international gravy train is over!”
It can be a long two years up there.
Congratulations, Rep. Gillibrand. Go get ’em.
Dan Warren lives in Scarborough and is a lawyer.
Comments are no longer available on this story