Mayor Tom Blake was expected this week to address a simmering controversy over health insurance benefits offered to the South Portland City Council.
In an interview prior to Wednesday’s council meeting, Blake said he planned to answer questions raised since October about free and discounted health benefits provided to the seven-member council. The insurance is the same that city workers get through the Maine Municipal Health Trust.
Meanwhile, City Attorney Sally Daggett has been asked to determine whether a 1977 council order allowing the health benefits is legal, given that it predates the 1987 city charter, which limits compensation for individual councilors to $3,000 per year.
The charter can only be amended by a citywide referendum. At press time, the city had not received a response from corporate counsel.
Blake said that he does not foresee the council having further discussion on health benefits, unless Daggett determines that the city charter needs to be amended to allow for it to continue.
Blake said he planned to answer the following three questions at Wednesday night’s council meeting:
• Why is the council offered health insurance that city employees receive? “It is compensation – fair compensation for work provided,” he said in a phone interview prior to the meeting.
• Do members get W2 forms to file with the IRS? “Yes.” The W-2s reflect the $3,000 in compensation councilors receive. The health insurance is tax-exempt, because it is treated as an employee benefit.
• Do part-time city workers receive health insurance? “Yes.” Part-time city employees who work between 20 and 35 hours per week can get health coverage on a prorated basis. But insurance costs for councilors are not prorated.
Councilors get free individual insurance. They pay none of the $6,347 annual premium for individuals.
Councilors pay between $1,500 and $3,000 for family health insurance that costs between $11,300 to $15,500, depending on how many dependents are enrolled.
“I do believe, frankly, that providing free health insurance to councilors does encourage incumbent councilors to run for re-election, and, when termed-out, to select election back to the council,” said resident Dan Mooers, writing in the South Portlander, an online news blog.
Mooers raised questions about health benefits for council members last fall during a televised candidate forum at City Hall.
Other members of the public have also weighed in. Serving on the City Council “is a true public service position and if we start to offer too much we will end up like big cities and having career politicians,” said resident Gary Crosby, who previously made an unsuccessful bid for a council seat.
“The last thing that should happen is for any board to vote themselves a raise.”
Six of the seven members are enrolled in city-sponsored health plans at a cost of $70,000 per year. Councilor Patti Smith is the only councilor to opt out of the program.
The South Portland School Board is not eligible for the insurance.
Concerns about health benefits for city councilors come at a time of cutbacks due to the recession. The city is looking at rising health insurance costs for next fiscal year.
According to John McGough, the city’s human resources director: “Effective January 1, 2009, the health plan rate adjustment for the city of South Portland is (rising by) 9.29 percent. The estimated increase to the budget over last year’s cost is $380,542.”
Most other southern Maine cities and towns do not provide free or discounted health insurance to elected officials. Cape Elizabeth, Scarborough, Saco, Bangor and Westbrook are among the municipalities that do not offer health insurance.
Augusta dropped free and discounted health insurance for city and school board members in the mid-1990s because of costs. Lewiston allows councilors to enroll in the city’s health plan at full price.
Portland councilors receive free individual health insurance and discounted family plans. But Portland is self-insured and can forgo some of the costs – and mandated benefits – the Maine Municipal Health Trust must cover by law.
City officials are unsure about how the practice started. South Portland City Manager Jim Gailey said records indicate the council voted to grant itself health insurance on Aug. 1, 1977, after one meeting.
Gailey indicated the plan also was discussed at a council workshop prior to approval. Over the years, the council has not discussed receiving health insurance benefits, and the charter is silent on the issue.
In other business, the council was expected to take a first vote on revisions to an ordinance governing beach access for pets.
The existing ordinance allows people to walk their dogs at Willard Beach year round. Dog walkers are limited to 6-9 a.m. in the late spring and summer. They can walk their dogs all day in the winter months. Dogs are allowed off-leash on the beach.
Proposed revisions to the ordinance require owners to be able to demonstrate to police or animal control officers that their pets are under voice control. The ordinance also changes the hours by which people can walk their dog on the beach to 7-9 a.m. and 7-9 p.m. in the summer. Fines for problem dogs or for not picking up waste are detailed in the revised ordinance. Dogs must be leashed on all public roads and byways as well as on the greenbelt and in Mill Creek Park.
The revised ordinance goes into much more detail about dog etiquette and the penalties for disobeying city law.
Comments are no longer available on this story