South Portland City Council workshops will be opened up for public comment under a trial program proposed by Mayor Tom Blake.
The council agreed late Monday night to relax rules that forbid public comment at the twice monthly workshops, where policy proposals are reviewed and discussed.
“This gets people involved,” Blake said, when he introduced the idea. “They see that the council is listening to them, and they don’t think everything is a done deal.”
Blake said that getting public input at workshops may actually save city staff time, because people may have valuable information the council needs to make decisions.
At issue are the Monday night City Council work sessions, where members roll up their sleeves to review policy proposals and critical questions facing the city – such as allowing pets at Willard Beach, expanding recycling to include condominium residents or imposing regulations on tattoo parlors.
The public is routinely not permitted to speak at workshops, unless specifically asked by councilors. Public comment is allowed at the twice-monthly City Council meetings. The policy has sometimes caused confusion and frustration by residents who attend workshops and want to share information or an opinion.
The trial program will start immediately and run through Sept. 1, 2009, at which time councilors will decide whether to allow public comments on a permanent basis. Members of the public will get up to two minutes each to speak on issues that are on the workshop agenda.
“I like hearing from folks at the front end of an issue, as much as possible,” said freshman Councilor Patti Smith. Her comments were supported by Councilors Jim Soule and Tom Coward.
No formal vote was taken on whether to allow public comments. But councilors reached consensus to support Blake’s proposal after lengthy debate and hearing concerns voiced by Councilors Linda Boudreau, Maxine Beecher and Jim Hughes.
They questioned whether large numbers of people may turn out to comment and unduly pressure members.
“You’re so impacted by a mob of people that (council) discussion becomes clouded,” Boudreau said. “All of a sudden, as a council member, you’re thinking, ‘Oh my God, this is what all these people want.’ But just because 50 people are sitting there doesn’t mean they have the answer.”
“I’m concerned about 300 people wearing dog leashes showing up and having two minutes to speak,” said Beecher, referring to pet owners who’ve lobbied the City Council to allow dog walkers on Willard Beach. “The whole point of large numbers is to intimidate.”
Although Boudreau, Beecher and Hughes said they were concerned that the public will pack workshops or rehash the same comments, Smith and Soule argued strongly that allowing limited public comment actually may inform the City Council and help members do their job.
“I don’t want to stifle anyone’s opportunity to speak. Getting input up front is a good idea,” said Soule.
Soule noted to fellow members that a frequent criticism he hears from the public is that councilors seem to have made up their minds before the public has had a chance to comment at City Council meetings. He said that allowing the early feedback would help to erase that perception.
He added that as long as the City Council was opening up public comment at regular workshops, it also should allow people to speak at the all-day budget workshops, even though it will lengthen the proceedings.
“These are the most important workshops,” he said.
Smith said she believes it is important for councilors to listen to each resident as an individual and not just view them as part of a single-minded group.
“We serve all of the people in this city, whether they show up for hearings singly or in a group,” she said. “I do believe that hearing all sides solidifies our decision-making and helps bring other ideas to light.”
Smith suggested that the mayor limit repetitive comments and coach members of the public on the importance of having people who can express the ideas of an entire group.
The arguments by Soule and Smith seemed to sway councilors, who agreed to give the comment period a trial run and evaluate it at midpoint.
“I’m just happy we’re going to give it a try,” Blake said at the end of the meeting.
Comments are no longer available on this story