4 min read

The South Portland City Charter states that councilors should receive $3,000 annually for their work.

But nowhere in the rules does it state that councilors may receive free individual health insurance or discounted family health plans.

Nevertheless, for as long as most City Hall workers can remember, South Portland’s top elected officials have been offered – and receive – full health benefits through the Maine Municipal Employees Health Trust, a nonprofit that administers and provides health insurance to municipal employees.

The insurance coverage, coupled with the annual stipends, brings the annual compensation for the seven-member council to roughly $87,000 in 2008.

The type and amount of compensation that councilors receive was an issue this fall at a forum for City Council candidates.

Longtime South Portland city attorney Dan Mooers questioned how much city councilors are required to pay for health insurance and why the compensation package is not mentioned in the city charter or as a city ordinance.

Advertisement

Mooers noted that the charter states that a city councilor should receive $3,000 in compensation and any increase must be by amendment.

“It seems to be me, when you talk in terms of compensation packages, which usually include health insurance, it’s a pretty close call on whether this can be done under the terms of the city charter,” Mooers said in an interview.

Currently, all seven city councilors have elected to receive health insurance under the Maine Municipal Employees Health Trust, according to the city.

South Portland city councilors have been eligible for employee health insurance for at least 25 years in a practice that grants them the same health benefits as city employees.

City Human Resources Director John McGough said he does not know when the practice of offering councilors health insurance started. “At this point, I do not have an exact date as to when city councilors’ health insurance benefits began. We do know that city councilors as far back as 1980 received health insurance,” he said in written correspondence with the newspaper.

He added that the policy for offering health insurance was likely adopted as a resolution by the council and may be found in council minutes prior to 1980.

Advertisement

Mooers noted that society’s concept of compensation for work may have changed since the charter was adopted.

He noted that the current practice appears to treat councilors like employees. “I, at least, don’t view a member of the City Council as an employee. They are decision makers in a council-manager form of government,” he said.

There are currently three city councilors enrolled in single coverage and four enrolled in family coverage for a total annual cost to the city of $65,670.64, according to city records.

The city’s 2008 cost for single coverage is $6,347.76. But participating councilors and city workers do not pay a contribution and receive single plans for free, McGough said.

The city’s 2008 cost for family coverage is $14,237.52. The city requires employees and city councilors enrolled in family coverage to contribute $2,580.68 annually to the overall cost, he said.

The Maine Municipal Association does not track how many cities and towns offer elected officials health insurance.

Advertisement

The Maine Municipal Employees Health Trust was established in 1980 for municipal employees. Currently, about 8,000 workers and their dependents are enrolled in the program, according to Christopher Lockwood, executive director of the Maine Municipal Association.

A newspaper survey of several southern Maine communities shows a range of practices and policies in compensating town and city councilors who serve elective office.

* In Saco, councilors do not receive health insurance. The mayor gets a yearly stipend of $3,600; councilors receive $1,200.

* Westbrook does not offer health insurance to elected officials. City councilors receive annual stipends of $3,000; the council president gets $3,500.

* In Lewiston, councilors are paid $2,700 per year. They are eligible for health insurance, if they pay the full cost for coverage. For individuals, the cost is $469.51 per month; family coverage, which includes a spouse and/or children, is $1,053.04 per month.

* Portland’s policies are most like the practices in South Portland. In Portland, the mayor, who is elected in a citywide vote, receives $7,195.20 yearly. Councilors get $5,669. Health insurance coverage through Anthem/Blue Cross is offered to the Portland City Council. Single plans are free. For a councilor and adult family member, the cost is $86.13 per week. For a councilor and a child, the cost is $35.47 per week.

Advertisement

In South Portland, freshman City Councilor Tom Blake said that serving on the council basically is like a part-time job and he considers health insurance part of the compensation package for the work he does.

Blake said he has received some questions from voters about councilors receiving health insurance since the issue was raised at the forum.

He said some voters worry that candidates may seek office to get the health insurance, instead of to serve the city.

Blake, a retired South Portland paramedic and firefighter, said he would not oppose turning the health benefit councilors are offered into a higher yearly stipend that can be applied toward insurance.

“It just removes the question from people’s mind that this is why a candidate might run for office.”

Mooers said he would like to see the city adopt a formal policy on health insurance if it continues offering coverage for city councilors.

Mooers said he is most concerned about transparency in city government.

“If you’re going to give benefits, why not put it in the charter or why not in the ordinance? Why is it apparently tucked away in a council order, which I don’t think takes on the significance of law?”

Comments are no longer available on this story