Two incumbents seeking re-election to the South Portland School Board face a pair of challengers whose frustrations as parents with the redistricting process motivated each of them to run.
Ralph Baxter Jr. and Karen Callaghan hope to retain their at-large seats on the School Board. Each has served a year, after filling vacancies by members who left office before their three-year terms expired in 2008.
Also running are newcomers Jay T. Allen and Kendall Fassett, who each have children attending South Portland elementary schools. Both say they hope to improve communication between the School Board and community, if elected.
The top two vote-getters of the four candidates will fill the two at-large seats on the seven-member board.
The South Portland School Board has come under greater scrutiny as the difficult economy has led to budget cutbacks. At the same time, the school department is asking residents to rebuild the aging high school. Voters rejected a $56 million construction plan in 2007, but the board plans to submit a less costly proposal in 2009.
The School Board also faced some criticism in earlier this year, when the boundaries for the city’s five elementary schools were redrawn to better balance a growing population of schoolchildren. Some parents complained at the time that the board and school department had not done enough planning to anticipate population shifts. Others complained that the same families had been subjected to prior redistricting efforts that resulted in children having to switch schools.
All four candidates for the School Board expressed the desire to make quality education in South Portland a priority. The following are descriptions of the candidates:
Baxter is the only candidate who has long experience on the School Board. Although Baxter most recently served one year on the board, he previously was on the School Board from 1993-2000. During his tenure, the board led the renovation and reconstruction of five of the city’s elementary schools. a sixth school was torn down.
Baxter said he sees the need to renovate and update the high school as the biggest issue facing the School Board. Baxter also serves on the Secondary Schools Facilities Committee, composed of residents and city leaders who are developing renovation plans for the high school.
He said the group is seeking feedback from voters by holding meetings at the city’s elementary schools.
“The real consistent comment we’re hearing from residents is that they did not like the artificial turf field or the second gym,” he said. “Beyond that, we hear everything from ‘We don’t need any improvements’ to ‘The school needs a ton of work.’ “
Baxter and his wife have two children, both students at South Portland High School.
Callaghan, the other incumbent seeking office, works as a part-time library aide. Callaghan said she is not campaigning on one specific issue or agenda. She said that her goal is to “make South Portand schools the best they can be.”
She identified some issues the School Board faces, such as a growing population of young students and a declining population of children in middle school and high school. The school department and board are working to develop long-range goals for managing the population shifts.
As a parent, Callaghan served on a committee of residents and school officials that developed the plan for renovating most of the elementary schools.
Callaghan has lived in South Portland for 25 years. She said the increase in students in the lower grades is not necessarily a reflection of more people moving to South Portland because they are drawn to the newly rebuilt neighborhood grammar schools. “South Portland always has been a popular place to live,” Callaghan said.
She added that the quality of the city’s schools and education are important to her, because “this is where children spend most of their time outside the home.”
Jay T. Allen, 47, said he hopes to better involve the community and residents in School Board decisions, if he is elected to office. Toward that end, Allen is developing his own Web site in which he will discuss School Board decisions and the reasons for them.
“One of the factors that motivated me to run was the redistricting ,” Allen said. “I felt it could have been better organized.”
Allen has children in kindergarten and second grade at Brown Elementary School. He said that he felt school officials made redistricting decisions prior to involving residents.
In seeking signatures from registered voters to get his name on the ballot, Allen said he heard from many people who want to be more involved in decision-making about the schools and city as a whole.
“There are two things I hope to accomplish,” Allen said. “One is to create a better dialogue with the community and the other is to better involve the bright and motivated people who live in the city.
“I want to make sure people are getting value for the $40 million that is being spent on school funding,” he said.
Fassett, 38, is a tax accountant with L.L. Bean who hopes to bring his budgeting skills to the School Board.
He and his wife have three young children and moved to South Portland from Vermont. Fassett said he previously worked as a finance and data manager for a solid waste district that covered 23 cities in the Montpelier area, and is familiar with the importance of consensus building.
Prior to redistricting, Fassett said he “never before considered the importance and sensitivity of the decisions.”
“I know how hard it is to get people to serve and I feel like I have the qualifications and background to fill the post. I felt it was my duty to step forward,” he said.
Fassett said he believes that there is a “real opportunity” for the School Board to reach out to the community, so that people feel “they are being listened to and heard… How you treat them is just as important as the decision you finally make. It’s all a balancing act, and we have to be willing to listen to all sides and all groups and opinions.”
Fassett said he believes it is key to the quality of education in South Portland to bring all the interested parties together.
“When I’ve gone door to door, people are telling me that decisions are made, but they feel that they are not part of the process.”
Comments are no longer available on this story