The scramble at the State House to do something to help Mainers with what are expected to be skyrocketing home heating bills this winter is creating a lot of rhetoric, but not a lot of cash – the one thing community agencies and churches say they need to make a difference.
A proposal to call a special session to dip into the state’s rainy day fund for short-term energy assistance has been rejected by Democratic leaders – a move Republicans say worries them because they fear a much larger Democratic proposal, including multi-million-dollar bonds, may be introduced after the November election.
Three committees have met or are meeting to propose ways of dealing with the energy crisis, including a pre-emergency task force created by the governor, a Heat Energy and Emergency Task Force hurriedly called by Democratic leaders Aug. 21 and the Appropriations Committee, which weighs in on all legislatively approved expenditures. That committee met Aug. 22 to get an update on what’s being done.
Dolores Vail of the Maine Council of Churches told the Appropriations Committee the message her members have for legislators is simple.
“Send money,” she said.
Gov. John Baldacci is pushing community-based volunteer efforts because the state has no readily available cash. A state budget deficit of more than $400 million is already predicted for next year and the fear is the hole will get bigger as sales and income tax revenues drop.
“This is really going to come down to neighbor helping neighbor, but they’re going to need money,” Vail said. “The churches are not the solution. In poor communities, they’re poor, too.”
Federal assistance
The federal government through its Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP) is expected to send $19 million in energy assistance as a start, and could double that amount if last year’s aid package is any indicator. The program in the 2007-2008 heating season distributed $38.5 million, or $750 per family, to around 50,000 low-income households in Maine. Much of the additional money, however, didn’t come until later in the year.
Community actions programs that distribute federal energy money already are reporting anywhere from 50 to 100 calls a day.
Baldacci said he was borrowing $6.75 million from the state’s low-income housing program to make more home heating and weatherization money available sooner, and avoid a special session, which Democratic leaders don’t support.
That money – $4.25 million for energy assistance, $1 million to help clean and tune up furnaces and $1.5 million for weatherization – will have to be paid back by the Legislature when it comes back into session early next year. The governor also has asked the Legislature to appropriate $3.5 million when it returns to cover emergencies for people who spend through their LIHEAP assistance or need help, but don’t meet the program’s income guidelines.
LIHEAP is available this year to those making 170 percent of what the federal government describes as poverty. That translates to an income of $17,680 for a single person or $36,040 for a family of four.
No special session
Republicans, and a few Democrats, have argued the Legislature should come back into a special session now to appropriate $10 million for LIHEAP. That money was added to the state’s rainy-day fund earlier this year for this type of emergency.
“The governor, the Democrats and the Republicans are all saying, in this winter heating season, we need to add some state dollars to LIHEAP to assure some reasonable level of coverage and in the event the federal money arrives in the last minute,” said Sen. Richard Rosen, R-Hancock, the assistant minority leader.
“The only disagreement is whether you actually pay for it now and pay as you go, which is the Republican approach,” he said, versus encumbering the next Legislature.
Rosen said his fear is Democrats will try to get a much bigger funding package through next year, in the form of some type of energy or housing weatherization bond. Figures as high as $100 million have been floated.
“I think they want to link emergency funding to LIHEAP with some kind of Democratic energy proposal,” Rosen said.
Rep. Jeremy Fischer, D-Presque Isle, the House chairman of the Appropriations Committee, also would like to see the Legislature come back in now to appropriate $10 million from the rainy-day fund, and deal with larger energy programs after the new Legislature elected in November is sworn in. Fischer is not running for re-election.
“The fact is a lot of people aren’t going to be able to afford heating oil in October, November and December,” Fischer said. And, the community action programs that handle aid applications don’t have any money to help people who are just over the LIHEAP-income cap.
“They don’t really have any flexible funds,” he said, to help people who “don’t meet the income threshold by $1.”
Fischer said he believes the Democratic leadership’s reluctance to come back in for a special session is all tied to election-year politics and the fear that unpopular topics would be raised, like eliminating the gas tax or other “out of left field” proposals from the rank and file.
“People are playing politics with what is a serious issue,” he said.
Housing bond
The Maine Center for Economic Policy, which advocates shifting more government money to lower-income people, believes a long-term approach is the way to go, with a focus on building or retrofitting affordable housing to make it weather tight.
“With 80 percent of Maine homes relying on oil to heat their home, there is no escaping the need for emergency heating assistance and winterization kits for homes that are amenable to such techniques. However, you cannot put weather stripping on a door that doesn’t close,” Nicole Witherbee, the center’s federal budget analyst, told the Appropriations Committee.
“There should be thought given to passing a housing bond bill to raise new capital and there should be serious consideration given to how new federal housing dollars could be spent to redevelop low quality housing into green affordable housing,” she said.
Two other sources of funding are being considered for weatherization and housing projects, including $30 million or more that could come Maine’s way under the Housing and Economic Recovery Act recently passed by Congress to allow states and municipalities to buy up foreclosed properties and create affordable housing. Since Maine’s foreclosure rate is not as high as other states, the money could be used to make buildings more energy efficient, officials say.
A second source of funding is money generated by the auction of carbon trades or credits under the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative passed by Maine and other states in recent years. The first auction of carbon trades, which allows electric generators using fossil fuels to buy carbon trades to offset their pollution, is this September.
The carbon trades or offsets could raise between $11 million to $30 million over the course of a year, and 15 percent of that can be used to reduce carbon emissions related to home heating, by weatherizing homes or making furnaces more efficient. The rest of the money is supposed to be used to reduce electricity use.
Comments are no longer available on this story