When oil prices shot over $4 this summer, Gov. John Baldacci responded in mid-August by dedicating $4.25 million to increase the funding to the 50,000 Maine families getting federal fuel assistance, and setting aside another $3.25 million to help families who were at or near the federal fuel assistance level on an emergency basis in January.
It might sound like a bold, proactive move, but in terms of real dollars and real gallons of oil, $4.25 million amounts to about $85 per needy household, which at $4 per gallon buys just over 21 gallons of oil. According to MaineHousing, the independent state authority that manages the federal Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program, that’s about 2 percent of the 800 to 1,000 gallons the average LIHEAP household needs to keep warm.
By all accounts, the coming winter will be a dire one for many families, and the pressure is on state and federal agencies, as well as local nonprofits, to help keep Mainers warm.
Last year, emergency federal appropriations brought the total LIHEAP aid to about $750 per household, enough to buy about 300 gallons of oil; an additional 700 gallons would have cost a family $1,750. This year, without emergency funds, the federal appropriation stands at $415 per family; with the additional state funds, families will get $500 to pay for about 125 gallons of oil; an additional 875 gallons of oil at this winter’s prices could run $3,500 or more.
“It’s not enough,” said Dan Simpson, manager of public information for MaineHousing.
Simpson and other state officials are optimistic that the federal government will step in with a significant increase to poorer residents in states with cold climates this winter; if that didn’t occur, the results would be almost unthinkable.
About 10 percent of Maine households receive LIHEAP assistance; another 10 percent are eligible, according to MaineHousing.
“I don’t think the government is going to allow people to freeze to death but … people are going to have financial problems,” Simpson said. “I think people will make it through, but I think there will be some serious (situations).”
Simpson’s hope is that the federal assistance to LIHEAP-eligible families (income of $36,040 or less for a family of four) will double at the beginning of the winter to about $830 per household, and that the winter will be a mild one. Beyond that, he said, Maine residents are going to have to make an extra effort to help their neighbors if everyone is to make it through the coming winter.
“Part of it is going to depend on community response,” he said. “About half of the people who get LIHEAP are elderly… If it’s a cold winter and they don’t have oil, they’re going to need some sort of help.”
Local organizations, such as Project GRACE in Scarborough, are optimistic that residents will be more generous this winter, despite their own financial stresses, if they know their neighbors are truly in need. From the Great Depression to the ice storm of 1998, Mainers have a tendency to step up to the plate when the government can’t or doesn’t. But nationwide, people tend to cut down on their financial donations to charity when finances tighten, which leaves service agencies like the United Way with fewer resources when they’re needed most. The United Way of Greater Portland is setting the same fundraising target this year as last year – $8.7 million – but “it’s certainly going to be a stretch,” considering the economy, said Nicole Avery, vice president of development.
Before fuel prices went through the roof, Maine already had the 35th lowest per capita income and the sixth highest tax rate of the 50 states, according to federal government statistics. A recent study by the Maine Public Spending Research Group indicates that the average Maine household spent $45,419 on overall expenses, $1,980 more than the median income of $43,439, and the gap between income and expenses that hasn’t improved much in recent years.
For the 80 percent of Maine households that heat with oil, much of the financial stress can be directly attributed to oil prices that have increased about 560 percent, from less than $25 a barrel prior to 2003 to more than $140 a barrel this summer on the New York Mercantile Exchange.
Not only are LIHEAP-eligible families facing increases of close to $2,000 or more in heating bills this winter, they can also expect to pay $6,000 a year to gas up two 10-year-old cars with average gas mileage and average annual commuting distance. Prior to the oil price explosion, when gas prices were about $1.25 per gallon, two adults driving two 10-year-old cars 15,000 miles a year would have spent about $1,875 a year in gas.
Nationwide, the effect of rising fuel prices are reflected in higher numbers of families filing for bankruptcy, having their utilities cut off, getting behind on car payments and applying for food stamps. The U.S. Department of Agriculture reports that rising energy prices combined with stagnant wages have combined to increase the number of working families needing help paying for food: more than 41 percent of those on food stamps were the working poor in 2006, up from 30 percent a decade earlier.
In Maine, the Auburn-based Good Shepherd Food Bank, the clearinghouse for the state’s local food banks, reports that 10 percent of Maine households – 141,000 people – have some degree of “food insecurity.” According to the food bank, one in three jobs in Maine does not pay enough to cover the basic needs of a family of three.
On top of their direct energy cost increases, Maine families are facing more insidious increases in everything from the cost of soup to the cost of school sports. In Scarborough, the Board of Education sought to soften this year’s school budget growth – major increases came from the costs of heat and bus fuel – by charging students more for everything from lunch to sports.
The cost of school meals increased about 10 cents in all categories, from school breakfast ($1.15) to high school lunch ($2.65). Participation in extra-curricular activities now costs $50 per student per activity, with a maximum cost of $150 per student per year or $250 per family. In previous years, the cost was $12, $48 and $60, respectively.
Despite the increase in costs to individual students, their parents are also paying a 4.13 percent increase in school taxes. In other towns, school tax increases are even higher.
At the grocery store, Mainers face a 6 percent increase in food prices, according to USDA projections. Health insurance premiums also continue to climb, although not at the double-digit rates seen in previous years.
Given the all-around financial pressures, Peter Rines, certification program manager for Maine Fire Training, which is a division of Southern Maine Community College, believes more residents will be turning to stoves and space heaters, increasing the number of fires this year, and others may turn the heat down to dangerously low temperatures.
“They’re going to be turning the heat down,” he says. “Check on your neighbor, especially if they’re elderly or live alone … this is going to be a neighbor-helping-neighbor winter.”
Eileen Whynot of the Southern Maine Agency on Aging says the economy hasn’t yet affected donor support, but it is beginning to affect both volunteers, many of whom are elderly themselves, and the organization’s purchasing power.
“The way the price of fuel is affecting us, it’s affecting our volunteers,” Whynot said. “People are needing to claim mileage (for delivering Meals on Wheels) when maybe they didn’t before … It’s worrisome that if we have a snowy winter, that people may just say, ‘I can’t do this anymore.'”
Project GRACE in Scarborough is already planning to team up with town officials, churches and community members to keep Scarborough’s most vulnerable residents warm if and when state and federal funds run out.
Mary, Rollo, executive director, says the community just needs to plan better to help out neighbors this winter. And, she thinks there are sufficient financial resources among town residents to help avoid a crisis.
“One thing, and we really believe this – is that there is enough,” she said. “Secondly, you can’t operate under fear. If we operate under fear, you’re not able to give it your best.”
Comments are no longer available on this story