Summer is dead long before its official demise on Sept. 21.
Daylight has nearly completed half of its voyage to the nadir of winter long before that sad fact is recognized on the calendar. Similarly, changes in political opinion may not be recognized until they are well under way – and it seems a safe bet that such changes are gestating here in Maine. A look under the tarpaulin of current political “wisdom” might reveal a few hidden opinions about taxes.
According to most of those who give public vent to opinions, as well as chambers of commerce and a few morose editors, taxes are the bane of Maine. The state’s taxpayers are consistently claimed to be severely abused – and dire results ranging from deathly outmigration to state bankruptcy are routinely and widely forecast. One gets the impression that nothing is hated worse than taxes. Not even seat belts. Or Maine winters.
Despite all that smoke, there really may be very little fire. The only truly accurate measure of “public opinion” is at the ballot box – and ballot history indicates things are pretty cool, taxwise. Dominated for nearly two generations by Democrats, no Maine government in living memory has addressed the broad tax problem. Yet the voters consistently return Democrats to Augusta to run the ship of state. (We did have one Republican governor 25 years ago, but he raised the sales tax by 20 percent.) Is it possible that beneath the chatter of anti-taxers hums the gentle tone of a reasonably well-satisfied body politic?
Or, at least a public that considers government services worth the cost?
It’s a good question, and one that is likely to be at least partially answered in November, when the people’s initiative to overturn the increased tax on booze finds its way to the ballot box. Do the 72,432 certified petition signatures to reject this new tax on the elixir of life signify the underlying attitude of Maineiacs toward the tax burden?
Maybe.
But it’s also possible that the voters will prefer to have booze continue its contribution to the Dirigo health plan. Maybe the people will feel that the benefits from Dirigo are worth a dime a stein of that famous Dutch beverage, Budweiser.
It’s early yet. The forces who object to the petition – those who support the tax – have yet to make much campaign noise, but when they do, they have a great weapon available. They can hire the fastest gun in the Maine media, Dennis Bailey, a brilliant operator who hasn’t seen a proposal he couldn’t defeat. Since the booze-tax issue will boil down to a yes or no vote – and the no vote will save the tax – the defense should call Dennis off the bench.
Further evidence of the true position of taxes on the mental scale of Maineiacs is the brouhaha over the sale of pristine Maine groundwater in York County to an international corporate conglomerate. Large corporations (except General Dynamics, masquerading as Bath Iron Works, which has had a stranglehold on Maine since the earth cooled) are generally distrusted and disliked by Maineiacs. All this particular proposal took to produce a rejection was for the corporation to become visible. The debate was local, held in the arena of neighborhood gossip, letters to the editor, hand-painted signs, backyard barbeques and morning coffee shops. In other words, hot air.
But it worked. Unlike the Legislature, which is more or less insulated from local matters of the moment, water district trustees are local folks who have to brave the gauntlet of their fellow citizens every day.
Consequently, regardless of income – which, in the long run, translates to taxes – the trustees caved. Nestle Inc. and its bottles were sent back to Switzerland, or wherever.
But yet, a faint sound of tax facts, statistics and reason can be heard in the distance bubbling up from the University of Common Sense. Maybe, somehow, people will come to realize the facts about Maine water – its abundance, its annual surplus and waste, its potential as a continually renewing resource. Perhaps it will occur to folks that the state as a whole could benefit from the controlled and taxed sale of water. For example, a dime or so a gallon extraction tax on bottled water could ease the chill laid on the Old Port bar scene by the new booze tax.
Or, Maineiacs may prefer “life as it ought to be,” even if payment for such life requires taxes.
Rodney Quinn, who lives in Gorham, is a former Maine secretary of state. He can be reached at rquinn@maine.rr.com.
Comments are no longer available on this story