5 min read

Mike:Finally the circus has left town.

Thursday, the Red Sox gave PITA (if you don’t know what that means-Google it) slugger Manny Ramirez his wish and shipped him out of town, completing a three-way deal with the Pirates and Dodgers that sends Ramirez to Los Angeles and Pittsburgh’s left fielder Jason Bay to Boston.

While some (I’m looking at you Todd) may bemoan the loss of Manny’s potent bat in the Sox lineup, I say good riddance!

(Aside from Todd: You’re right Mike, I am going to miss Manny’s offense and his presence in the middle of that batting order, but I agree it was time for him to go after all the comments he made over the past week combined with his recently self-imposed two-game benching.)

Sure, Manny has been a force for the Sox in two championship runs, but his production is just not worth all of his other crap. He didn’t want to be here, plain and simple, and I think he was on the verge of quitting on the Sox like he did in 2006, so why not trade him and get something for him?

I will admit that I don’t think the trade improves the Sox this year, and in fact, I think their 2008 playoff chances have taken a hit, but sometimes you need to think long term, and Manny was not going to be the answer here, especially not for $20 million per season.

Advertisement

The problem I have with Theo’s moves at the deadline is that nothing was done to shore up the bullpen, and in fact, the deal removes a pitcher from Boston’s pen, as Craig Hansen is going to Pittsburgh (along with Brandon Moss).

But this could also be just like 2004 all over again, with Theo shipping a fading superstar on the verge of free agency who had become a problem in the clubhouse (Nomar) and getting a productive player in return. And don’t discount the fact that Manny’s teammates had become sick of his act, so removing him from that clubhouse could certainly improve team chemistry as the Sox look to catch the Rays.

In short, Manny deserves the fans’ gratitude for what he has done for the team over the years, but that’s it. Players like Manny don’t care about anything but their paycheck, so why should fans care about them? Plus, his comments about Boston “not deserving a player like me,” were the last straw.

You got it wrong Manny, you don’t deserve Boston. Don’t let the door hit you in the butt on your way out.

Goodbye and good riddance.

Todd:While I do agree that Ramirez had to go, it’s only because his recent words and actions forced the hand of the Red Sox front office. This isn’t quite like the ’04 Nomar deal because the impetus behind that trade was Garciaparra’s physical health and whether the Sox could count on him in the lineup the remainder of that season. Theo Epstein was also addressing a need to upgrade the team’s defense, and in hindsight it’s obvious that deal was a large reason why Boston won its first World Series in 86 years (just as obvious as Manny’s on-field contributions are a large reason the Sox have won two titles this decade).

Advertisement

Fast forward to the present, I realize there was a possibility that Manny could have quit on the Sox, but I don’t believe that would’ve happened as long as they remained in contention. By Ramirez ‘shooting his way out of Dodge’, Theo had no choice but to ship him out of Boston but it came at a high cost. Not only did the Sox have to include Hansen and Moss in this three-team deal but also lost the two compensatory draft picks they would’ve received if they kept Manny till season’s end, declined his option and offered him arbitration. So in essence the Sox gave up Ramirez, four other players AND cash and all they got in return was Jason Bay.

Bay is a player with solid offensive numbers, but let’s see how he responds to the bright lights of Fenway and playing in the first meaningful games of his professional baseball career. Regarding the long-term decision behind this deal, Bay is only signed through the end of 2009 and his agent just happens to be the same Scott Boras who may have played a part in getting Manny out of town and to free agency.

Mike, if you don’t think this trade improves the team it probably made more sense from a business standpoint for the Sox to hang on to Manny and deal with him in the offseason. To give you another perspective, an informal survey of American League pitchers and team executives taken yesterday have them all celebrating Manny’s departure from the Boston lineup. In particular, the Angels of LA/Anaheim/Orange County/SoCal are probably celebrating the most between the Manny trade and their own acquisition of big bat Mark Teixeira. You might want to write in Mike Scioscia’s boys right now for the AL pennant as long as they stay healthy.

Watching the Ramirez situation with the Sox come to a head this week has me thinking this is another great example of a ‘sports divorce’ between a player and team. In the last decade former Sox like Nomar, Pedro Martinez and now Manny have all produced memorable sports moments but eventually left town with anything but dignity.

To complete this analogy, Red Sox fans are like the children of a sports marriage: they root for both their team and those who play on it, yet they have no control over who actually plays on the team and are forced to take sides when the sports relationship is irreparably damaged. And for the Red Sox fans who are young children, good luck explaining to them why one of their favorite ballplayers no longer plays for their team.

Speaking of choosing loyalty to team or player, how must fans of the Green Bay Packers feel these days? The latest twist in the Brett Favre saga is that the Packers are offering their NFL record-setting QB a staggering $20M to stay retired. Can you believe that?? Just like with Manny, I’m guessing Favre prefers not to accept the ‘option’ of twenty million but instead declare his own form of free agency and force the Pack to trade their local icon.

Mike Higgins and Todd Bloniarz have been observing Boston sports all of their lives. In their professional lives, Mike is the sports editor for Current Publishing and Todd has called and covered games for various outlets ranging from high school, college and even the Boston Red Sox for one memorable inning on NESN during the 2003 season!

We

Comments are no longer available on this story