A 20-year-old Scarborough man avoided a jail sentence Tuesday for the 2007 car crash last summer that killed his 14-year-old foster sister.
With the victim’s mother and aunt advocating on his behalf, Cumberland County Superior Court Judge William Broderick ordered John Heger to pay a $1,000 fine and surrender his license for 30 days for criminal speed and 180 days for driving to endanger. It will be up to the secretary of state to determine whether those suspensions are consecutive or concurrent, said Robert “Bud” Ellis, assistant district attorney.
Heger had pleaded guilty to the two motor vehicle violations earlier this summer. At his court hearing, Ellis asked the court to sentence Heger to a six-month jail term. Heger’s attorney asked for fines and a license suspension.
The aunt and mother of the victim, Scarborough Middle School student Brittany Burke, also asked the judge for leniency. Brittany’s mother, Winnifred Burke, has said Heger was a good influence and like a big brother to Brittany.
“Both (Brittany’s mother and aunt) spoke very powerfully to the count and said they hold no ill will toward the young man. They want nothing but the best for him. They feel that it was an accident, a tragic accident,” Ellis said.
Heger was “very emotional” and expressed “sincere remorse,” Ellis said.
Police say Burke was a passenger in Heger’s car – and wearing a seat belt – when Heger rounded a corner on Black Point Road on July 12, 2007, lost control and smashed into some trees. According to police, Heger was driving in excess of 60 miles per hour. He lost control near a road sign marking a speed limit decrease from 35 to 25 mph.
Heger claimed he drove off the road because he swerved to avoid a deer.
He was originally charged with manslaughter, a felony punishable by up to 20 years in prison, but prosecutors reduced the charges when it became clear that Heger was not under the influence of drugs and there were no other aggravating factors.
“It was an extremely unusual case,” Ellis said. “Unlike any manslaughter case I’ve dealt with in my 13 years here, there’s no drugs, there’s no alcohol, there’s no eluding police, there’s no hitting parked cars and running over pedestrians. This is a case where an inexperienced driver was simply going too fast and lost control of the vehicle.”
Ellis said he was “a little conflicted about it myself,” but requested jail time because the accident resulted in a person’s death.
Both Ellis and Heger’s attorney, Thomas Marjerison of Portland, said Winnifred Burke’s willingness to forgive Heger swayed the outcome of the case.
“Winnifred Burke recognized that it was a tragic accident and did the right thing,” he said. “She forgave John for the mistake.”
Marjerison said Heger was devastated by Brittany’s death.
“He feels horribly about it. It’s something he has to live with for the rest of his life,” Marjerison said. “He loved Brittany Burke like his own sister.”
He said Heger has decided to go into the Navy and will ship out within the next four months.
Comments are no longer available on this story