Conservation groups have renewed an effort to get the state to force Sappi Fine Paper to provide passage for migratory fish on the Presumpscot River, after the paper company pulled out of a deal to remove the Cumberland Mills Dam.
The Friends of the Presumpscot River, American Rivers, the Maine Department of Marine Resources and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service have requested that the Maine Department of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife continue with a process that began more than a year ago to determine whether the state can make Sappi install a fish passageway on the Cumberland Mills Dam.
The process to remove the Cumberland Mills Dam, which many conservationists see as the key to restoring migratory fish to the river, halted a year ago when Sappi and the conservation groups announced a deal to remove the dam.
However, public hearings on removal of the dam could begin again as early as a month from now, according to Andrea Erskine, administrative assistant to the commissioner of Inland Fisheries and Wildlife.
The dam, and other dams farther upstream, prevents sea-run species of fish like Atlantic salmon from traveling from the ocean to fresh bodies of water to spawn. In addition to salmon, other sea-run fish native to the Presumpscot River are blueback herring, alewife and shad.
Sappi spokeswoman Brooke Carey said she couldn’t give details about why the company decided to pull out of dam removal deal, but that the company had decided not to move forward with it.
Dusti Faucher, president of Friends of the Presumpscot River, said Sappi had indicted that costs of removing the dam were higher than anticipated.
“Obviously, we’re very disappointed,” said Faucher. “It’s something we’ve worked on for a long time.”
Under the deal announced last July, Sappi agreed to remove the Cumberland Mills Dam, opening the waterway by May 2011. In lieu of fish passageways, Sappi agreed to a “trap and truck” program, in which fish impeded by the Saccarappa Dam would be caught and transported upriver. The estimated cost of the deal to Sappi was $6 million.
However, the deal wasn’t universally endorsed by conservation groups. The Friends of Sebago Lake hailed the breakdown of the deal this week, saying it will be an opportunity to force a better outcome for migratory fish.
Roger Wheeler, president of Friends of Sebago Lake, said the deal made too many concessions to Sappi. Wheeler argued the “truck and trap” program, rather than requiring fish passageways, would have made it so fish wouldn’t have been able to travel the length of the river until 2030. Furthermore, he said, salmon don’t fare well in tanks, where they would be held when trucked down the river.
According to Erskine, in coming weeks, Inland Fisheries and Wildlife Commissioner Roland Martin will meet with Assistant Attorney General Mark Randlett to determine how to proceed. She said it is likely the commissioner will decide to continue with the process of holding public hearings before making a decision on whether to force Sappi to remove the dam. By law, the state can require any company to install a fish passage on an inland waterway.
“We’re just picking up where we left off” before the deal was made, Faucher said.
Erskine said Inland Fisheries and Wildlife could hold the first public hearing as soon as a month from now. Depending on what happens, more public hearings could be held before a decision is made. She said it was hard to estimate how the process would go because this is the first time the department has held a public hearing to dispute fish passage, although the state law governing dams on inland waterways dates back to the 1800s.
Faucher said the Friends of the Presumpscot River would try in the public hearings to prove to the commissioner that there is a biological reason the fish need to be able to travel the Presumpscot.
“I imagine Sappi will fight it any way they can,” Wheeler said, “but at least there’s a chance for real restoration.”
The Presumpscot River and its dams have long been a point of contention for conservation groups.
Many of the dams previously had fish passageways installed in them, but after years of neglect and aging they were no longer operational, according to Faucher. They were never replaced because the river was considered too polluted for fish migration. However, in recent years the quality of the river has improved to the point where fish would be able to use it again, she said. Bringing back the fish populations upstream would result in the return of a host of other animals and birds, such as eagles and osprey.
Sappi has already fought the state in court over whether the state had the right to force it to install fish passages in its five hydro-power dams, which are regulated by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. In May 2006, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that states have the right to regulate their inland waterways, but the ruling did not include the Cumberland Mills Dam, because it does not provide hydro power and is not regulated by the federal government.
In the Supreme Court ruling, Sappi is not forced to install the fish passageways on the other dams until a passage is installed at the Cumberland Mills Dam, because it is the first dam on the river migratory fish meet, preventing them from even reaching the others.
Comments are no longer available on this story