3 min read

Ronald Reagan taught that government itself was the problem, and that the goal of every thinking American should be to shrink it. He has become the poster boy of those who wish to rely on the market for solutions.

A part of his “trickle down” theory – the cup of the rich overflows sufficiently to provide adequate drippings for those lower down the table of life – was the belief that private enterprise outstrips government in efficiency and accountability.

Much of this balderdash has evaporated in the light of experience and common sense – a circumstance duly noted by his acolyte, the younger Bush, under whose stewardship government expenditures have expanded beyond the wildest socialist dreams. Nevertheless, the private enterprise zealots aren’t entirely wrong. There really are some activities in which government efficiency is exceeded by private endeavor.

.

That consideration became the subject of a coffee shop klatch last week in Gorham. It was agreed that private organizations involved in improving life in poorer parts of the world show great skill in what they do. They have learned to communicate cause and effect in a personal way. Sick and abused children are helped through volunteer donations. For a dollar or two a month, names, pictures, and personal letters are exchanged between donor and donee – an idea that certainly motivates the donors. The discussion group agreed that this is one type of organizational efficiency that might be studied by government.

Seizing on the admission of a fellow coffee drinker that his taxes had been $20,000 dollars this year, the group wondered if his contribution could be connected to explicit results. What kind of individual results caused by his taxes can we identify as supporting a specific U.S. goal? To choose one: The U.S. is spending about $400 billion “spreading democracy” in Iraq this year. That’s about one-eighth of total government expenditures. A similar chunk of a tax bill of $20,000 is $2,500. What would that $2,500 purchase? And how could it be personalized as part of “spreading democracy”?

Advertisement

The answer was offered by a young hanger-on who, since he was not wearing a flag pin, was obviously not a patriot and might even have been a liberal. He suggested two common U.S. gifts to Iraq, one inexpensive and one quite dear: M16 bullets at 28 cents each, and aircraft missiles – (JDAMs) – at $23,294 apiece. Thus, $2,500 would have purchased about 650 M16 bullets or about 1/10th of one of these JDAM beauties.

Simple enough. And as far as beneficiaries were concerned, it seemed reasonable to assume that one bullet out of 650 should end up installed in at least one Iraqi. As for the JDAMs, while Army “incident” reports often differ a good deal from those of local observers, it also seems fair to assign about 10 “collateral damage” Iraqis per missile – thus awarding a direct share to the Gorham taxpayer of one beneficiary/recipient.

But how to personalize this contribution was a problem the group couldn’t solve. A pen-pal program was out, since few in Gorham read Arabic. As far as a personal picture was concerned, pictures taken before “actions” were generally not available, and pictures taken after visitation by either M16 bullets or JDAM flowerings often did not offer much resemblance to individuals.

Nevertheless, the coffee klatch maintained that a personalization program was a worthwhile effort and should be pursued. As they summarized the discussion: What better way to provide individual taxpayers a warm glow when knowing just how their tax monies had been spent in a worthy cause?

Rodney Quinn, who lives in Gorham, is a former Maine secretary of state. He can be contacted at rquinn@maine.rr.com.

Comments are no longer available on this story