Still reeling from an estimated $10 million loss in 2005, southern Maine’s shellfish industry is facing another devastating blow from red tide, a microscopic algae that renders clams, oysters, mussels and carnivorous snails highly toxic to humans.
Earlier this month, the Department of Marine Resources shut down coastal areas from Pernaquid Point, near Bristol, to the New Hamsphire border to shellfish gathering, but spared the Scarborough River.
That changed Monday, when samples taken from the Scarborough River also showed high levels of toxins.
Image courtesy of Google Maps.
The Scarborough River, the source of about 75 percent of the shellfish harvested in Scarborough, was closed Monday “as of 1 p.m,” Harbormaster Dave Corbeau reported.
“It could be a while (until it reopens),” he said. “You don’t know when it’s going to open. There’s no indication …”
It’s another blow to Scarborough’s 28 commercial clammers, who have already lost about 25 percent of their clam beds due to pollution in the last year and a half.
“It’s devastating to these guys,” Corbeau said. “That’s when you make your money, is in the summertime. When it was closed back then (in 2005), it affected them immensely.”
“This time of year would be the time to put money in the bank,” said Scarborough clammer Terry Twomey. “Clammers always hope for the best, so we’re hoping it’s not going to close – but it always does.” He estimated that Scarborough’s clam beds have been closed for some period of time 10 of the last 15 seasons.
“Some people have other things to do,” he said. “Pretty much every year, you’ve got that threat out there.”
But experts say this summer could be as bad as, or worse than, 2005, when Maine harvesters and industry members lost an estimated $10 million to a red tide that closed an estimated 70 percent of the state’s shellfish beds for about six weeks during peak season, according to Deirdre Gilbert, special assistant to the commissioner of Marine Resources.
“There are large, large numbers of cysts out there compared to historic levels and compared to 2005,” said Don Anderson, a senior scientists at Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute in Massachusetts, who has studied northeastern red tides extensively.
“You’ve already got a fairly extensive area closed and it’s still early in the season,” Anderson said late last week. “In the next few days we’re not going to see anything get better. It should get worse.”
The harmful red tide is caused by an overabundance of toxic algae called Alexandrium fundyense, which is notorious for producing a toxin that accumulates in clams, mussels and other shellfish. While the toxin doesn’t affect the shellfish, it can cause potentially fatal paralytic shellfish poisoning in humans who eat them.
Researchers from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute noticed unusually high numbers of Alexandrium cysts, or seeds, on the ocean floor in late 2007 – about 30 percent more than the fall before the devastating red tide of 2005. Since then, an extremely wet winter and spring have washed land-based nutrients into the ocean to nourish the unwanted algae, and weather and wind patterns threaten to wash the algae toward the Maine coast, rather than out to sea.
Anderson said red tide in the Gulf of Maine appears to be a natural, cyclical occurrence, governed more by naturally occurring cycles in the ocean than by humans or pollution.
The Maine coast was virtually unaffected by red tide until 1972, he said, when there was a large bloom of toxic algae similar to that of 2005.
“That was followed by multiple decades, 20 or 30 years, where, at least for 20 years, there was frequent and high levels of toxicity,” he said. “(From 1994 to 2004) the levels and toxicity were reduced a lot … now we are on the upswing.”
Anderson said weather patterns and other factors will determine how long the red tide affects Maine shellfish. After it clears up, the toxin can remain in mussel tissue for a few weeks to a month, and a year or more in some clams, he said.
“It’s extremely toxic and there certainly were times during the 2005 bloom when if someone disobeyed the closures … half a meal of clams or mussels would have been fatal,” he said.
But Darcie Couture, Maine’s director of biotoxin monitoring for the Department of Marine Resources, says the state has an extremely effective monitoring program and no one who obeys the rules has been sickened by Alexandrium fundyense in recent years.
“In 2005 when we had the really bad event … the national media just took the story and ran it very negatively,” she said. “Even people who were still able to work were not able to make a living because people coming to Maine were afraid to eat the shellfish… Any shellfish that are on the market are going to be safe to eat,” she said.
In 2005, the state applied for $10 million in disaster relief from the federal government and eventually got about $2 million, of which $1.6 million was distributed to industry members directly affected by the closure in 2006.
There is no mechanism in place for out-of-work clammers – there are about 1,367 licensed – to receive aid in a more timely fashion, she said, although the state does provide them with information on traditional relief such as Targeted Aid to Needy Families and food stamps.
Also affected are harvesters of mussels, mahogany cohog, oysters, carnivorous snails, and other seafood, as well as seafood wholesalers.
“It’s just very hard, obviously, for people to know how long something like this is going to last,” she said. “There’s no mechanism, federally at least, to provide money quickly in a situation like this.”
Comments are no longer available on this story