The Massachusetts man charged in the deaths of two boaters on Long Lake in Harrison last summer now faces two civil suits filed in Cumberland County Superior Court last week.
Robert LaPointe, 39, of Medway, Mass.; his father, George LaPointe, of Ashland, Mass.; and Naples Casino, Inc., owners of Rick’s Cafe in Naples, were named as co-defendants in suits filed May 7 and 8 by representatives of the estates of Suzanne Groetzinger and Terry Raye Trott, who were killed in a boat collision Aug. 11.
The collision that killed Trott and Groetzinger occured when the 32-foot Sunsation operated by Robert LaPointe struck the 14-foot boat carrying Groetzinger, 44 and Trott, 55.LaPointe and his passenger, Nicole Randall of Bridgton suffered minor injuries.
Blaine Groetzinger filed as a representative of his mother’s estate. Dana Hall and Maureen Gillis filed as personal representative and special administrator of Trott’s estate.
The suits seek unspecified damages from Robert LaPointe for the suffering and deaths of Groetzinger and Trott, from Naples Casino for negligently serving alcohol to LaPointe, and from George LaPointe for accepting a parcel of land from his son after learning of the plaintiffs’ intent to sue.
The civil suits charge that LaPointe “negligently and with actual or implied malice” collided with the boat operated by Trott, causing pain, suffering, and death to Groetzinger and Trott. Proving negligence in a civil suit requires that the plaintiff prove that it is more likely than not that the defendent acted in a way a normal person wouldn’t, according to Groetzinger’s lawyer, Benjamin Gideon of Berman & Simmons in Portland, Lewiston, and Bangor.
The suits also charge that because earlier that day LaPointe drank alcohol at Rick’s Cafe, located on the Naples Causeway, those at the cafe should have seen LaPointe was intoxicated and would pose a danger to others because he would be operating his boat.
Gideon said that he has information that LaPointe was at Rick’s Cafe the day of the collision, but at this point he does not know exactly when or how much he drank. Owners of Naples Casino Inc. did not return calls by press time.
The state limit for wrongful death is $500,000 for loss of comfort and companionship and emotional distress and $75,000 for punitive damages. There is no limit to damages due to economic loss. Since Groetzinger was caring for her minor son, Jacob, at the time of her death, Blaine Groetzinger will pursue all three categories of damages, according to Gideon.
The limit in the Maine Liquor Liability Act for damages arising from any one incident is $250,000.
The final section of the suits charge that LaPointe transferred ownership of a 100-acre property he owned with his wife Heather on Whitney Road in Bridgton to his father, George LaPointe a week before he was arraigned and after LaPointe learned of the plaintiff’s intent to sue and understood that his boat insurance would not be sufficient to compensate the victims.
As of Dec. 31, LaPointe owned three properties in Bridgton, two with his wife, Heather, and one with his wife and father, George. The first two properties, both on Buswell road, were valued by the town at more than $250,000. The LaPointes bought the third property on Wildhaven road Dec. 24 for $25,000. The 100-acre property contested in the suit, which was valued at more than $111,000, was transferred from LaPointe to his father around Nov. 19.
While responses from the defendants are not yet on record for the civil cases, motions to suppress evidence gathered in the criminal case are under consideration at Cumberland County Superior Court.
Filed by LaPointe’s attorney, Neale Duffett, and heard on April 30 and May 1, the motion seeks to strike from the record statements LaPointe made to the police and a test of his blood alcohol level. There is no court date scheduled for the criminal case.
LaPointe’s blood-alcohol content was found to be .11 about two hours after the crash. Maine’s legal limit for operating a boat or other motor vehicle is .08 percent.
LaPointe was indicted by a Cumberland County grand jury on two counts of manslaughter, four counts of aggravated operating under the influence, and one count of reckless conduct with a dangerous weapon. He pleaded not guilty in November to the charges.
The next step is for the defendents to answer the civil case. After that, the court will set a schedule, which will most likely include eight months time for gathering evidence and a trial date in a year or so, said Gideon.
“I don’t think there’s any amount of money in the world that could compensate the three children of Suzanne Groetzinger for losing their 44-year-old mom,” said Gideon.
Comments are no longer available on this story