2 min read

It’s difficult to imagine the trauma that watching a dog being killed by two pit bulls might inflict on a young girl.

Unfortunately, that’s just what happened last week in Scarborough, where two pit bulls came after an 11-year-old girl who was walking with her mother, Laurie Caiazzo, and their 3-month-old Pomeranian.

If anything good can come out of this, it might be new ways to avoid tragedies like these, which are clearly caused by negligent dog owners who should be barred from owning dogs.

If a dog bites a person or kills another dog, the owner faces only a $100 fine, according to Scarborough police officer Mike Beeler. That penalty seems light, particularly with owners who have a record of negligence.

The two dogs that killed the Pomeranian are now being held at the Animal Refuge League in Westbrook. The dogs – Menace and Ty – could be euthanized. While that may be necessary, it’s a shame, because their behavior is more likely a result of the way they were bred and raised.

Pit bulls have gained a bad reputation. Some argue that, because they were bred as fighting dogs, they are more aggressive and dangerous. Some communities have even adopted bans.

Advertisement

Those bans, however, are misguided. Pit bulls are strong dogs that can be trained to be aggressive, but most familiar with the breed say they make good pets for responsible owners.

It’s the owners that need to be held responsible for the actions of their dogs. The owner in this case, Joseph Bowser, received four summonses for keeping dangerous dogs, according to Scarborough Animal Control Officer Chris Creps. One of the dogs, Menace, has been under a confinement order since July, after a neighbor complained the dog had come after her and her children at a neighboring home.

The confinement order and the summonses didn’t stop the attack last week, and that’s not surprising. A $100 fine is little deterrent, and an owner who is letting a dog run loose regularly in the first place is not likely to change habits because of a confinement order.

Neighbors are frustrated that their repeated complaints about the dogs didn’t lead to their removal from the home. That’s understandable. No neighborhood should have to be terrorized repeatedly be a couple of aggressive dogs.

Dangerous dogs need to be removed from the homes where they have been poorly raised and treated, and owners need to face stiffer penalties for letting dangerous dogs loose in neighborhoods. Owners who neglect animals shouldn’t be allowed to own more.

It would be unfortunate if the only result of this attack were three dead dogs, none of which can reasonably be held accountable for what happened.

Brendan Moran, editor

Comments are no longer available on this story