Democrats in the Legislature Tuesday worked out a compromise on funding Dirigo Health that would double the tax on beer and wine and create a new tax on soda to help keep the subsidized insurance program going next year.
Those combined taxes would raise an estimated $17 million. The plan also calls for putting a 1.8 percent tax on all claims paid by health insurance companies and self-insured businesses to raise about $36 million and taking $3 million to $5 million out of the Fund for Healthy Maine – money currently earmarked for smoking prevention campaigns.
The proposal replaces a 50 cent hike in the cigarette tax to pay for Dirigo that was supported by Gov. John Baldacci and a controversial assessment already in place that also hits health insurance carriers and the self-insured.
The House supported the plan in a 72-69 vote Tuesday afternoon, even though Democrats there had the votes to pass the cigarette tax. The Senate approved a slightly modified version in an 18-17 vote.
“We just can’t keep going after cigarettes,” said Sen. Nancy Sullivan, D-York, the chairman of the Insurance and Financial Services Committee. “We’ve raised it too much.”
At the same time, Sullivan said, the state cannot abandon those people who rely on Dirigo for their health insurance.
Senate Majority Leader Libby Mitchell, D-Kennebec, agreed. “We have an opportunity here to keep people insured,” she said. “It’s not about saving Dirigo. It’s about access to health care.”
Sen. John Nutting, D-Androscoggin, one of the holdouts on the cigarette tax, supported the alternative tax plan.
“It’s time that we realized alcohol and soda have adverse effects on health care costs just as cigarettes do,” said Nutting. “There are seven spoonfuls of sugar in every single (soda) can,” he said, making the connection between childhood obesity and soda.
The tax hike on beer and wine would not affect Maine wineries or micro-breweries based here, who would be exempt under the proposal. It would raise the excise tax on all other malt liquor from 25 cents to 54 cents a gallon and raise the excise tax on a gallon of wine from 30 cents to 65 cents. The tax on soda would be a new tax charged at the rate of $4 per gallon on syrup used to make soda or 42 cents per gallon of bottled soda.
Sen. Bill Diamond, D-Cumberland, supported the proposal, but said it will be the last time he votes for special revenue to keep Dirigo afloat.
“The funding is not pretty. I’m not pleased with what we had to do. This is not the way we should fund the program like this,” he said, but the state has to accept its responsibility for people enrolled in the program.
The subsidized insurance plan, which currently covers 13,681 people, is due to run out of money by February 2009 without additional funding. Part of its funding also goes to pay Maine’s share of enrolling 5,650 parents in a special state Medicaid program that exceeds federal income guidelines – a program Republicans unsuccessfully tried to cut back in state budget negotiations.
Lobbyists for the industries that would be taxed under the plan criticized the lack of any public input and the apparent willingness of some Democrats to go back on their no-new-tax pledge.
“It would be unfortunate that after all the hard work of the Legislature and the governor to balance the state budget without any increase in taxes, that they would go and put a tax hike on this without any opportunity for the public to comment,” said Newell Augur, director of the Maine Beverage Association, before the vote.
The compromise funding package is designed to replace the controversial savings offset payment, which is essentially a surcharge on paid claims and has to be negotiated every year through lengthy proceedings before the state’s superintendent of insurance. This year’s assessment was set at $34 million.
Majority Leader Rep. Hannah Pingree, D-North Haven, said the funding was really in the hands of the Senate, since Democrats hold such a slim majority there. In the House, there are 90 Democrats, 59 Republicans and two independents.
“We asked the Senate what could they pass,” she said. “This package came from them.”
Comments are no longer available on this story