About 40 teachers and parents packed the Scarborough Board of Education’s meeting April 3 over concerns that Scarborough students don’t spend enough time in school.
At issue was the school calendar, which this year included 14 early release days for teacher professional development.
Parents – and school board members – say that’s too many. And some parents also say the Scarborough school day, at six hours, is too short.
While the school board can’t extend the school day without renegotiating the teacher contract, board members could – and did – send administrators back to the drawing board after reviewing a proposed schedule that cut back the number of early release days to seven.
Board members peppered administrators with questions about what they do with the professional development time, and criticized the schedule for having too much time off and too few full weeks of school.
Board member John Cole said staff members need to find a way to do their training at a time that doesn’t affect their students, like doctors and other professionals.
“(In other professions), you don’t ask your clients to go home so you can do your development work,” he said to a burst of applause from the audience. Several teachers shook their heads.
“The idea of having early release, for me – I would rather see it set to zero,” he said. “I’d rather see development … after your customers leave the building. The priority is to teach those kids.”
The purpose of professional development is to improve and increase a teacher’s knowledge and skills. Scarborough had seven early release days until the current school year, when the board increased the frequency to 14, based on studies that show staff development is more effective in regular, shorter sessions rather than lumped together in a few whirlwind days at the beginning of the year.
But parents were not happy seeing their children arrive home from school early every other Wednesday.
“The education system has to be first and foremost driven by what’s the best educational format,” sad Bob Mitchell, a parent and former board member. He said 14 early release days is too many.
“There seems to be a huge number of early release days,” said parent Peter Schild. “We’re looking for something … (that wouldn’t) impact the kids’ education so much.”
Superintendent David Doyle said teachers had also had problems with the 14-day schedule.
“The days were coming along too frequently for them to practice the techniques (they were learning),” he said. “They found the two week period was really too short.”
In his proposed calendar, Doyle had reduced the number of early release days to seven, along with five full professional development days. The early release days, as proposed, would have been all Fridays, and most were scheduled before a Monday that was either a holiday or a full professional development day.
But the number of long weekends didn’t sit well with board member Annalee Rosenblatt, who called it a “fantasy” schedule.
“Is this the real world? Is this really sending the right message?” she asked. “It’s just unbelievable that we have so few months that (contain four) full weeks.”
Board members also objected to the proposed two-week December vacation and the pre-Labor Day start.
The board voted 3-2 to reject the proposed calendar, Jackie Perry and Chairman Chris Brownsey voting in favor of it and Cole, Rosenblatt and Jane Wiseman opposed. Board members Brian Dell’Olio and Colleen Stazko were absent.
Teachers and administrators say the staff development days are critical to their success as educators, and afford them invaluable time to collaborate with other teachers and try new instructional methods.
Teachers have to submit a plan for what they will be working on in the beginning of the year and write a report at the end of the year showing what they have tried and learned.
“Yes, it’s disruptive in the calendar, but we feel it’s important as far as growing our teachers,” said Monique Culbertson, the district’s director of curriculum and assessment.
Jeremy Carter, the board’s student representative, said he knows the training time is important to staff members. “I haven’t had a teacher in three years of high school who didn’t mention (professional development),” he said.
He said 14 early release days were “noticeable” to students, but seven are not. “I wouldn’t really call them a disruption, as they’ve been called,” he said.
According to the Center for Public Education, American students on average attend school 6.5 hours a day. Schools in the Midwest have the longest average days, 6.9 hours for middle and high school. The state of Maine requires schools to be open 180 days per year.
Comments are no longer available on this story