4 min read

Matt and Amy Mattingly own and operate the PineCrest Inn, named Gorham’s Business of the Year 2008 by Friends of Baxter Memorial Library.

The Mattinglys took over a struggling bed and breakfast in 2005 and increased business by 350 percent in the first 18 months.

Mattingly, 40, is originally from North Anson and his wife, Amy, is a native of Cincinnati, Ohio. Both are graduates of Thomas Moore College in Kentucky and met while working at the college a few years after graduating. While living in Ohio, the pair spent seven years looking at and studying prospective properties. They found their Gorham property, at 91 South St., which was a bed and breakfast advertised on the Internet, and bought it in a private sale. Mattingly’s family has a history of innkeeping. His great-great grandmother owned a hotel in Pellston, Mich. The couple has two daughters. Abby, 12, is a Gorham Middle School student and Zoe, 10, attends the Village School.

Mattingly, who is the guest speaker Thursday, April 10, at the Gorham Business & Civic Exchange annual meeting, took time out from work to talk with the American Journal about the challenges of inkeeping and what makes his inn special.

Q: Why did you buy this inn?

A: The value of the real estate was worth more than the business. My assessment was that the business could be turned around.

Advertisement

Q: How did you do it?

A: People would come and go and never meet the innkeepers. It was very loosely run. You could put bread in toasters and you bused your own table. We redefined the business. It’s not your grandmother’s bed and breakfast. We operate more as an inn.

Q: What services do you provide now?

A: We do a full, hot gourmet breakfast served every morning at private tables. We offer guests private dinners. We have a private restaurant open Friday nights. We have a private club, PineCrest Club. We have a little pub. A guest can catch a game and have a pint. We do wine tasting. Wine makers come from all over the world – Australia, Argentina Chile, California. We do catering for the stars who perform at the L.L. Bean summer concert series.

Q: What about entertainment?

A: We do house concerts. I opened the evening Saturday night with a song my 10-year old wrote. Charlie King was in last summer and he has performed all over the world.

Advertisement

Q: From where do your guests come?

A: We have people coming from all over the world. I market this place as the most convenient inn in Maine. I market basically from Kennebunk to Freeport, or from the Old Port to Naples. This is the place they should stay. A lot stay here on the way to Bar Harbor. I don’t encourage inn hopping. People from Texas or Australia will day trip to anywhere. We have people who live in Gorham stay here. They become tourists in their own town.

Q: Why do your guests come to Maine?

A: They come for a huge variety of reasons – shopping and eating. Portland is one of the top three culinary food destinations in the United States. They come for food. Every year, two or three restaurants rank in the top 15 in the country.

Q: Do guests come back?

A: The returns once were 2 or 3 percent. We are now hitting 25 percent returning guests. Last summer, we turned away 200 requests for rooms.

Advertisement

Q: Do you screen guests?

A: If someone calls and is rude and nasty, we just might be full.

Q: Is your inn expensive?

A: We are the most affordable of this kind in the region – $107 to $159 per night. We are family friendly.

Q: What amenities do you provide?

A: DVD, cable, YFI, Internet docking stations, high-grade linens, Maine magazines, plush robes imported from Egypt, pampering items in private baths.

Advertisement

Q: Does the Gorham economy benefit from your business?

A: I send 1,000 people each year to Sebago Brewing and Lucky Thai restaurants.

Q: Where do you buy your food?

A: All our herbs are grown locally and we buy in season fruit locally. Maple syrup comes from Merrifields and a lot of our meats are from Wolf Neck Farm. By June, 90 percent of our food will be produced in Maine. (Guests) will forego organic for something local. They want the taste of Maine.

Q: Who decorated the inn?

A: The decorating was all Amy. It’s my job to get them here. It’s Amy’s job to get them to come back. All the details are Amy’s responsibilities.

Advertisement

Q: Have any famous people stayed in the inn?

A: We’re discreet, we’ve had authors – Tom Hazuka was here two weeks ago. Linda Tripp’s lawyer was here for a week. A French diplomat came with his family. We did a wine exchange as he brought wine from the French embassy. Sometimes people come and go without knowing who they are.

Q: What celebrity would you like to meet?

A: I’d like to have Randy Newman come and play.

Q: What’s the history of the inn?

A: The original structure burned in 1825. It was owned by a doctor and friends reframed the house in one day. Someone carved it into an apartment building. It became an inn in 1993.

(Matt 1) – Matt Mattingly, owner of PineCrest Inn.

Comments are no longer available on this story