3 min read

The conversion of the Lighthouse Inn motel to condominium units has left the Scarborough Town Council nearly as unhappy as the motel’s neighbors, but councilors continue to insist that there’s nothing they can do.

Councilors drew that conclusion – again – after requesting a 90-page legal report from Town Manager Ron Owens and Town Attorney Chris Vaniotis.

The council reviewed that report at its regular meeting April 2.

“The end result was not what anyone was looking for, whether it’s the owners, whether it’s the neighbors, whether it’s the town,” council Chairman Jeffrey Messer said. “I classify this (resolution) as a lose-lose.”

Pine Point residents had asked the town to re-examine whether the conversion to condominium ownership constituted a change of use requiring town approval. The town’s position is that it does not. The report reiterated the town’s prior position, and councilors indicated that they would not seek a second opinion.

Residents fear that the motel will become an unsafe and possibly disruptive part-time dwelling place for 22 owners – or even 22 families – when the units begin to sell. The motel has been a beacon for controversy since 2004, when owners Nicholas and Peter Truman proposed to tear down the building and replace it with eight condominiums that neighbors said were out of keeping with nearby homes.

Advertisement

In response to neighbors’ latest concerns, Messer asked Owens to prepare a report on the issues the neighbors had raised, specifically responding to 68 questions. Messer said he is now satisfied that the town has no legal right to object to the conversion.

About a dozen residents came to the council meeting to reiterate their unhappiness with the plans and ask that the town get a second legal opinion. The residents were also upset that the council had indefinitely tabled an ordinance proposed last year that would have regulated “condo-hotels.”

“I would urge you to be sure that you are absolutely right, that this is the way you want to go,” Pine Point resident Jack Callahan said.

Elaine Richer urged the council to revisit the condo-hotel ordinance, and warned that while the condominium’s declaration limits use to the summer months, it takes only 75 percent of the condominium association’s members to make a change.

“If you have two owners, it’s very easy to get to 75 percent,” she said, referring to the Trumans.

Resident Judy Shirk pointed to language in the condominium declarations that prohibits kitchens, but defines a kitchen as a “cook-top and oven.” Nothing, she said, prohibits the new owners from putting in one or the other, along with countertops, microwaves, garbage disposals, toasters, coffee-makers and all the other trimmings of a kitchen.

Advertisement

“Common sense dictates that the owner will put in a kitchen,” she said. “As long as they don’t have a stove and a cook-top, they haven’t broken the rules.”

She worried that the motel could soon have 22 families living in it, despite the fact that the building doesn’t have interconnected smoke detectors and other necessary upgrades.

“The building is not going to be a motel. It is going to be some hybrid multiplex with no oversight,” she said.

Other residents suggested that the town had knuckled under to the Trumans out of fear of litigation.

Council members said they had tabled the ordinance because it became unwieldy and impossible to understand, and it was unclear exactly what it was intended to accomplish.

“I can’t vote on something I can’t even explain to the public,” Messer said.

Advertisement

Councilor Sylvia Most agreed with Messer that the report had revealed “no smoking gun.”

“What happened is legal and within the rights of the owners to do,” she said. “While it’s not an ideal outcome, it’s a legal one.”

Councilor Carol Rancourt said she is “very concerned about 22 owners in an old building” and that the town will need to conduct frequent inspections to ensure that the rooms are not being improperly converted or used.

Councilor Judy Roy expressed hope that the Trumans’ latest plan may not be their last.

“What if no one wants to buy this little room?” she said. “They

may be back.”

Comments are no longer available on this story