4 min read

Expulsion hearings began Monday for the first two of 10 students accused of vandalizing Cape Elizabeth High School last week, but it was a 10-day suspension – not expulsion – that the School Board handed down.

Board members, Superintendent Alan Hawkins, school Principal Jeffrey Shedd, the students themselves and their families and supporters declined to comment before or after Monday’s hearings, either on the vandalism or the hearings themselves.

School officials refused to identify the students.

Hawkins said the hearings would likely continue throughout the week.

The board met at 4 p.m. Monday in the town office building and went into a 45-minute executive session with school attorney Daniel Rose, then went behind closed doors for approximately 90 minutes with the first student, a young man in a blue blazer and tie with an earring in one ear, and a couple who appeared to be his parents.

A woman who also declined comment entered the meeting at one point to speak on the boy’s behalf.

Advertisement

The board then entered into deliberations for about 45 minutes before returning to public session and voted to suspend the student “for being deliberately disobedient” for 10 days, in addition to the 10 days he had already been suspended following the vandalism. Board member Patricia Brigham, who left immediately after the vote due to a prior commitment, was the lone dissentign vote. She did not immediately return a call seeking comment Tuesday.

The student will also have to follow “behavioral contract conditions” to be determined by the superintendent. Hawkins said details of the contract – including participation in sports, Project Graduation or the graduation ceremony itself – have yet to be worked out. He also declined to comment on community service or repayment of the damages, estimated at more than $10,000.

“I’m sorry, again. I apologize. I’m sorry,” the teen said after the school board voted to suspend him.

The family and supporters hugged and smiled after leaving the conference room.

At about 7 p.m., the board began the hearing for the second student, a clean-cut young man in a blue dress shirt and tie. He had been waiting in the council chambers with several adults who appeared to be family members for approximately three hours.

An hour later, he was also suspended for 10 days “for being deliberately disobedient” and told to adhere to a behavior contract.

Advertisement

His only words to the board were, “Thank you.”

Hawkins declined to specify what in the boys’ actions – allegedly breaking into and vandalizing the school in the middle of the night – constituted “being deliberately disobedient.”

Officials say the 10 students gained access to the school when one of them climbed in through an open window late at night on March 23 S and unlocked a door. The school has no alarms, and the students disabled security video cameras with tape so they would not be identified.

They then allegedly emptied classrooms of furniture, stuffed furniture in bathroom stalls, removed and damaged ceiling tiles, smeared peanut butter on door knobs and wrote obscene and drug-related graffiti on the walls. The damage was discovered by a custodian Monday morning, and by that evening the 10 had been identified and allegedly confessed.

School officials said it appeared that the vandalism was a senior prank that went overboard.

The students had a lone vocal supporter Monday evening in Carolyn Homa, a mother of three teenagers whose daughter is a senior at the high school but was not involved in the vandalism. Homa waited for about an hour outside the closed-door meeting to hand-deliver a letter she had written to the board asking leniency for the teens, but eventually left without delivering it.

Advertisement

She said she was worried about the teens’ ability to get beyond the incident and get on with their lives, especially considering the prominent media coverage the vandalism has received.

“As an adult, you know that things are going to get better. Kids don’t know that,” she said.

Given the publicity and calls for expulsion, she said, “I wouldn’t blame a kid in this whole school system to never come forward and be honest about (a mistake).”

She said she thought a three-day suspension, community service and restitution would be an appropriate punishment.

“I don’t want these kids’ futures damaged,” she said. “I think the fear involved is enough. I just don’t want to see anyone get hurt … I can’t imagine what these poor families are going through.”

Senior Libby Cummings, who was not at the meeting, said there is a “widespread agreement among students and teachers” that the vandals don’t deserve expulsion.

“That’s awesome!” she said when she learned they would receive a 10-day suspension instead.

Comments are no longer available on this story