Chain-link fences barricade the empty door and window frames, and a few stones, fallen from the walls, are scattered on the weeded dirt where there once was a floor.
Roofless and crumbling, the formerly stately Goddard Mansion is now a mere shell, its insides gutted by vandalism and controlled burns, the gracious rooms where officers lived left to the imagination.
But the building is an icon to Fort Willams Park visitors, and to many residents of the town who remember its grander days.
“It’s got a tremendous amount of emotional value,” said Charles Wilson, Fort Williams Advisory Commission chairman.
Emotional value, however, can be expensive. And in light of a projected cost of nearly $500,000 over the course of five years just to maintain the mansion as a ruin, town officials are facing the unpalatable decision of whether to simply tear it down.
“It’s kind of beyond the point where restoration would be an option,” said Councilor James Rowe. “It’s becoming … more of a liability than an asset.”
Constructed in the 1850s for Col. John Goddard and his family, the stone Italianate mansion predates the fort itself, but has no known historical value. It’s not unusually old for the area, and its less than 50 years as a private residence were apparently unremarkable. Its only real connection to Fort Williams – which was built at the turn of the century – is the fact that it’s located in the park.
“Personally, I don’t (see any reason to save it),” said local historian Norman Jordan. “I’m a historical person, but they’ve let it get beyond the point where it could be saved easily. It’s never going to be anything more than a shell. It’s kind of interesting if you walk through, on picnics and stuff down there, but it’s really kind of an eyesore now.
“I think they could use the money better somewhere else,” he added.
Jordan said he doesn’t know much about Col. Goddard and his family, except that he had read somewhere the colonel was an out-of-town lumber baron who “claimed his net worth … was equal to everyone else in town (put together).” The colonel served in the Army during the Civil War, but little else is commonly known about him. If any of his descendants live in town, there aren’t any Goddards listed in the phone book.
The mansion was acquired by the federal government in 1900 and used as quarters for noncommissioned officers. By the time the town purchased the fort in the 1960s, it was already in disrepair, although it still had a roof and windows. Vandalism and fires over the years further deteriorated it, and in 1981 the Town Council began to consider razing it.
“(Local contractor) Jimmy Murray was on his way to knock it down with a wrecking ball,” said Henry Adams, a local history buff. “A couple of ladies in town said, ‘Spare this great…’ – whatever they said. ‘Over my dead body, they’re going to take it down.'”
Instead, the town opted to gut the inside with a controlled burn, leaving only the stone shell standing. In the mid-1980s, the tops of the walls were capped for stabilization.
But in the ensuing 20 years, wind, rain and snow have eaten away at the stone walls from the inside, crumbling mortar and loosening stones.
“A masonry building is designed to withstand the weather conditions from the outside, but not from the inside,” Wilson explained. “It’s deteriorating from the inside out.”
The Fort Williams Advisory Commission recently selected a consulting firm, Renner Woodworth, to study the building and suggest a course of action. The commission and the firm are still negotiating the scope and cost of the study, Wilson said.
Wilson has a few guesses about what that course of action the architects might ultimately recommend, but one thing that seems clear is that maintaining the ruin, to the tune of half a million dollars, is not a likely option.
“We really don’t think that’s a good expenditure of tax dollars,” he said.
Several ideas have been floated that would leave a part of the structure – the arched main doorway, for example – intact as a memorial to the mansion, perhaps with an interpretive display showing photos of the building and telling its history. There’s also been talk of taking down the walls most of the way to the ground and creating a garden inside the house’s footprint. There’s also been discussion of somehow converting it into a picnic structure.
“There’s enough sentimental value for the structure that we’d like to keep something without spending a small fortune,” Wilson said.
Even if the advisory commission had an extra $500,000 sitting around, the mansion is far from the top of the commission’s priority list. More pressing concerns include replacing or repairing and upgrading the stone bleachers on Parade Field, where Cape Elizabeth graduations are held every year, and possibly digging up a buried gun battery near the Lighthouse Museum and making it accessible to the public. Replacing the portable outhouses with restrooms and improving the entrance to the park area also on the commission’s long-term “to do” list.
Wilson said the commission will probably make a recommendation to the Town Council about what to do with the Goddard Mansion within six months to one year.
“We’re looking at a way we can preserve the … emotional value,” he said. “Because there isn’t a lot of historical value.”
Adams knows what he thinks.
“It’s a horrible thing that ought to come down,” he said. “They’re spending an awful lot of money to preserve something that’s not a part of Fort Williams. It was never a part of Fort Williams. Col. Goddard, he was never a part of Fort Williams.”
He said he sees no reason to keep it standing.
“They’re spending an absolutely inordinate amount of money to preserve a thing that has no historical value whatsoever,” he said.
Comments are no longer available on this story